My 12yo boxer loves the treats! He has many health issues, but the C&C products are easy on his teeth and stomach. My boy gets a Senior(Easy) box every month and extra chicken feet and duck necks to have a daily treat. He gets one every morning after a walk and he prances towards the shed in excitement. He tries to demand more if we are in the yard, often successfully. Delivery is nice and quick, the packaging is good, although indeed, the treats smell (duh!), so I keep them in an air-tight container in zip-lock bags in the shed. Overall, could not be happier! Oh, and they have a loyalty program!