Its' a bit of a difficult review to write really, Yes I was extremely please with the product the Firedog Gun dog training vest (waxed Cotton) its is well made a fits the purpose exactly. The only problem I had was that after careful measuring I ordered the medium and was sent a large, I needed it for that weekend so have kept as it's fine for over a coat, especially a thick down one, but I'll have to order a medium for the summer. Then I was sent a review request and I put the same as above, funnily enough all that has appeared in the reviews section is the 5 stars I awarded the product no mention of the wrong size which seems odd and has annoyed me slightly at it was not meant as a criticism more to let people know about the sizing.