After reading great reviews about Cohorted boxes it took me a few months before I managed to get one ordered. I don't know if this way of doing it adds to the exclusivity or demand for the boxes? When it arrived, the box is excellent quality, like a gift. In the September box I received; theBalm Nude Tude eyeshadow palette RRP £35, along with theBalm eyelid primer. 12 eyeshadows palette in a cute retro palette. Colours very similar to Naked palette, but excellent colour payoff, especially when combined with the primer. Also received Nars velvet matte lip pencil, I love lip pencils, the colour payoff from the pencil, but with the benefits of a lipstick, brilliant product, non drying. I was a little disappointed to receive 2 shower gel products as my final two products, albeit Gucci and Molton Brown, so I knocked a star off for that. I didn't see the need for two shower gels, and felt they were there to fill the box, perhaps having one more bigger value blush instead of two smaller value products the same may have been a better option. Overall I was pleased with the box, it is all items I would use, ut perhaps wouldn't necessarily buy myself. I will consider repurchasing Cohorted boxes in the future.