So, all throughout August there were sneak peeks from Cohorted for the September box, which was the NARS dual eyeshadow. Come September, I was eagerly waiting for my package and was informed on 6th September it's been dispatched and told it will arrive max by 12th September. I didn't receive anything on 12th September so I contacted them and they said the item was never even dispatched and they'll make sure to get me my box asap. The next day I did get my box, but there was no NARS eyeshadow as advertised even in their September box booklet, and no Benefit dual lipstick either! Both items were replaced with old products left over from previous months boxes such as the Doucce palette. So disappointed and don't trust Cohorted to subscribe ever again. Half the things being described in my information booklet had been replaced with lower grade products. Feeling a bit conned.