I have purchased from cohorted before and was really impressed with the value and service, however it seems that lately cohorted's price has gone up which makes it similar to other deals you can find if you shop around. I ordered the first beauty box and was disappointed to find products that were available on the site not long before as I had in fact bought one, if I knew this then I would not have purchased as I was under the impression the products were going to be all new. The idea of a luxury make up item hidden in a few boxes is brilliant, and despite my initial reservations it is this factor which will probably lead me to buy a cohorted box again (+ I no longer buy from cohorted due to the aforementioned price increase) The customer service for cohorted remains exceptional and the beauty boxes are very exciting!