Our puppy basset Hecate loves both the puppy dry and trays. Eaten in no time. They smell ok to us humans too so doesn’t smell the kitchen out where she eats. Saurus the adult boxer that li es with Hecate likes your tinned dog food. He tried the dry but he’s not too keen. He especially likes the salmon trays too as a treat. Hecate can’t wait to be big enough to try the salmon as she snifferos around when saurus has that one. The trays are well packed and always arrive in tact including the dry. The tins are sometimes dinted but it’s always to do with the courier. Overall great product and love the flexibility of altering my subscription I’ve had to do it a few times.