My dog enjoys the treats a lot. The pig ears are occasionally a miss for him, but other times he is all for it. The treats are easy on his teeth and stomach, no issues with fur either. I am subscribed to the monthly deliveries since September, it works like a charm every time. Delivery is good, the packaging is nice, mostly recyclable, and it's always consistent. The treats are smelly and look... well, like animal parts they are, and my household asked me to handle it myself, store and feed outside. I'm not that sensitive, but they have a point. I can't say it smells worse than deep-fried fish ;) I'm very happy with the product and the company and ordered more treats for my dog to let him have one a day.