My German Shepherd puppy loves these and they are lovely and soft so don’t interrupt training like some treats that the pup has to chew. I like that they don’t crumble in your pocket even when you break them into smaller pieces and my pup also now enjoys all the other flavoured treats. The fact that they’re 100% natural and low cal is very important and the plant a tree an added bonus..... what a great idea. I now have a recurring order to make sure we never run out as well as saving money. Denzel’s is a great product from an ethical company that gives great service. I have no hesitation in highly recommending Denzel’s!