I am no stranger to Vedder holsters as I own 4 of them, 3 of them are the Rapid Tuck. There's a reason I keep getting the Rapid Tuck for different pistols ( COMFORT WHILE BEING SECURE ). My S&W M&P 40C rides in one as does my Sig 365 X and my last Rapid Tuck purchase was for my S&W Shield Plus. The S&W 40C and the Sig 365 X still have good retention after 2 years of daily use but my latest Rapid Tuck for my Shiels Plus came looser than the others, I can barely hear the Kydex click when the pistol is inserted. I could have sent it back but I can live with it. I still recommend Vedder holster as I feel they are the best holsters made today.