Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

High-Key Volume Mascara - Midnight Reviews

4.5 Rating 641 Reviews
“I’m absolutely loving the High-Key Volume Mascara in Midnight. It gives incredible volume and definition without clumping, and my lashes look instantly fuller, longer, and beautifully lifted. It makes my eyes look more open and refreshed, which I especially love.”
Helpful Report
Posted 9 months ago
“Having looked for a good mascara for years, I’m thrilled to have found this one. Cannot recommend the High Key mascara highly enough. It does everything a mascara should. On my 4th tube of it now.”
Helpful Report
Posted 9 months ago
“Since the packaging has changed something is different. The old one was absolutely amazing!!! But ordered 3 tubes with the new look packaging & they have all been terrible in comparison. Goes on as if it's an old mascara that's been open for months. Either the formula has changed, or the new style tube doesn't keep it fresh. Doubt I'll repurchase.”
Helpful Report
Posted 9 months ago
“Since the packaging has changed something is different. The old one was absolutely amazing!!! But ordered 3 tubes with the new look packaging & they have all been terrible in comparison. Goes on as if it's an old mascara that's been open for months. Either the formula has changed, or the new style tube doesn't keep it fresh. Doubt I'll repurchase.”
Helpful Report
Posted 9 months ago
“Absolutely certain the formula has chnaged despite Beauty Bay claiming it hasnt. This used to be my go-to product, EVERYONE would compliment me on my eyelashes. I would never have considered trying another mascara, i used to buy it for frienda and family every gift-giving opportunity and recommend it to anyone who asked. But since the packagaging change, my eyelashes never go the way they used to. S extremely disappointed. False-lash effect no more.”
Helpful Report
Posted 9 months ago
“Absolutely certain the formula has chnaged despite Beauty Bay claiming it hasnt. This used to be my go-to product, EVERYONE would compliment me on my eyelashes. I would never have considered trying another mascara, i used to buy it for frienda and family every gift-giving opportunity and recommend it to anyone who asked. But since the packagaging change, my eyelashes never go the way they used to. S extremely disappointed. False-lash effect no more.”
Helpful Report
Posted 9 months ago
“I've been using this for a while and it was amazing, recently my order of 3 of these are new white tubes and the formula is completely different, very dry like its an old mascara, checked one of the others that is the same, won't but again now. As much as I apply not much is happending what a flop”
Helpful Report
Posted 9 months ago
“I've been using this for a while and it was amazing, recently my order of 3 of these are new white tubes and the formula is completely different, very dry like its an old mascara, checked one of the others that is the same, won't but again now. As much as I apply not much is happending what a flop”
Helpful Report
Posted 9 months ago