“I’ve tried so many now and I’m obsessed. Here is my rating of all the ones I tried.
Cookie butter 10/10
Cake pop 10/10
Frosted animal cookie almond 9/10
Sugar cookie 8/10
Cinnamon crunch 7/10
Apple pie 7/10
Halloween egg 10/10
Buckeyes 8/10
Chocolate hazelnut 5/10
Sometimes if a butter is runny I just pop it in the fridge for 10-15 minutes and it’s perfect. I put them in oats, on bananas, pancakes and eat right out of the jar! They are addicting”
“I was so excited to try the sugar cookie butter when it was released in July, all the reviews RAVE about this and I was excited for some Christmas flavor! Honestly I was pretty disappointed. It has sprinkles mixed in which is really cute, but the texture was very gritty. The flavor was like a very very rich but expired sugar cookie. Tried it on its own and on toast and the flavor was just too overpowering. I haven’t tried any other flavor and I like the idea with all the different flavors, but I feel like it/this flavor specifically is overhyped.”
“I can't get enough of the nut butters! I keep rice cakes and a jar of nut butter in my bag at all time to snack on in between clients and classes (I am a personal trainer and indoor cycling instructor). I got al the other cycling instructors hooked as well! haha. So far from the flavors i've tried- cinnamon crunch- AMAZING. Buckeye- another favorite. Cake Pop- LOVED my first jar, but the second jar I received is super runny so I hardly grab for it. Apple Pie- not a big fan as it taste more artificial. would probably be good in oats”
“I had tried the caramel apple (or something like that) about a year ago and wasn't super impressed, but ordered the frosted animal cookie last week and it's already gone. I love it on toast or eating it straight out of the container. It's a little grainy but I personally don't mind because the flavor is spot on. Will definitely buy again.”
