I own several things from Ashland. Most are small: Machine Gun Jack and Little Louise and a couple of Vault Key Holders. All in cordovan and one more Machine Gun Jack in a CXL or Dublin. I saw a video promoting the Fat Herbie, which I've had my eyes on for several years. The video shows the Herbie fitting into a jeans back pocket. That erased my concerns about the size. I ordered a Fat Herbie in Natural Cordovan (and a One Shot Card Case to accompany it). A couple of days later, I got my card case and a Fat Herbie in Natural CXL. As I told Phil and Matt, the wallet in Natural CXL is a beautiful wallet. But when you've decided on cordovan, you want cordovan. They were wonderful about correcting the error as fast as possible. I am a very happy repeat customer.