To be honest I usually buy from ciate when there is a sale as the price point is a little high for me, however I have only really used the mascara and nail polishes really until my recent purchase. The dewy skin base is just beautiful, wholeheartedly recommend, I also tried the eyeshadow formulas as well, the olive palette is divine, the shadows have a great consistency, pigmentation is wonderful and they blend like an absolute dream. Lip oil is lovely, really nice formula - non sticky and hydrating. I will definitely be keeping my eye on future releases and will certainly purchase again...also the delivery was the quickest I've experienced, it arrived so quick I had no idea it was my ciate order and was confused 😂 picture used ...I am wearing the olive palette.