We love it, the only thing that would make it totally perfect would be to have a material handle on top as I can give might mutley a power boost when he jumps in/out of the car. There is little to grap and the little ring on small size is quite small if struggling with cold wet fingers to get the clasp of lead on. We do love it still though. He finds it super comfy perfect fit which is has been difficult to find well fitting harness that fits small head neck and larger body. Dries quick when wet too. Love the ability to not have to pull off over his head and just unclip.