Absolutely excellent! I have a very VERY fussy rescue chihuahua. In the 18 months we have had him, we have tried every dog food known to mankind... and he has turned his nose up to the lot. However...then we discovered Poppys Picnic! He loves it. We tend to cook his in the oven. He waits outside the kitchen the whole time it's cooking and cooling. When I'm serving it he tries to climb up my legs, and for the 1st time ever, a clean bowl every single time! We get the meatballs, and the portion sizes are perfect and the pricing is exceptional for what you get. Highly recommend.