I give Scottish Kilt 5 stars. Its' strongest attribute is value. It is amazing what you get for what you pay. That said, there are critiques to be made. My family tartan, has a subdued blue in it. Instead, I received a bright purple. I researched the tartan more. Depending on computer monitor, some blues look purple and vice versa. More importantly though, the purple does more closely match what is in the Scottish Tartan Register. It's just very different from what I am familiar with and what you see if you google the family tartan. Long story short, more research on the tartan needed. I think Scottish Kilt delivered an attractive, well made product at pennies on the dollar. Authentic? Close enough. No regrets. Thank you to the people that labored to provide this great looking outfit.