I wish there was an option between good and excellent. My experience was very good! I just don’t feel I can say it was excellent. The order was received in a very timely manner. I really like the colors of the 1/2 inch glass (desert gold). My only disappointment was with the large amount of dust, tiny crumbs and small shards that came in my bag. I would totally expect some crumbs but it almost seemed like an excessive amount. I rinsed the glass and the crumbs looked like a big pile of sand! It was like I got the bottom of the “barrel”. I wish I would have taken a picture. It just seemed like a lot of waste at that cost. Overall I was satisfied with my experience. I would recommend and order from Starfire again. Thanks