The box is a great idea - six options, superb write-ups for each, and secure packaging. I have not had a chance to evaluate the recent box. Until now, I have not one a single sake that was above mediocre save 1.5 -- One was really satisfying, and one was a solid citizen that is readily available, even here in Quaker State. I have no illusions that I am an aficionado, but I have taken private classes with sake-specific sommeliers, drink sake often (compared to other US wines), and have traveled to Japan for direct experience. I've had better luck ordering items from the Tippysy website, relying on the descriptions for each. The samples are no Gekkan, but they're not up to the quality of other selections at Tippsy. I will continue with the subscription as I see it as a smart way to try new brands, regions, and rice processing techniques, but I hope I find some gems or even decent choices.