It’s ok but due to how much it pills on my skin, it really makes me miss using my tretinoin in a tube from the pharmacy that I had used for years previous. I don’t know if it’s just me but no matter how I apply this version of tretinoin-alone, ontop of a serum, on just a light moisturizer, no matter what it pills. I don’t have dry skin or peeling skin at all so this is super frustrating when I feel like half the fhe formula is scattered around my face in weird dried up clumps I’m never sure if it’s even penetrated into my skin. I literally use a pea sized amount like I always have. I’ve even tried to use less I’ve tried to use more. I don’t get it! The one thing I have found that SOMEWHAT helps is a specific Korean moisturizer I can put it on about an hour prior to future formula and as long as I do it really quick and don’t take more than 10-15 seconds rubbing it on then it usually doesn’t pill as much. I wish they’d add some type of squalane or something in this to make it a tiny bit less dry. Maybe I’ve just got a bad bottle? I never hear anyone else talk about this.