5* should be for the absolute exceptional. I only look at 1-4* reviews. I waited for a wet afternoon dog walk before review. 73%intensity, 98%coverage walking in woods and dry from neck to mid thigh. No leak around the collar seam or under the arms. No ingress around the sleeve cuffs -delighted. Game pouch great for dog lead and cargo pockets kept treats and poo bags dry. How well the seams around the hand warmer pockets stand up will be the test of time. Zip and poppers seem good quality. The only thing missing is a zipped chest pocket for phone and match tickets