We have been using these along our lakeside frontage and dock for 5 years now. It does a great job warding off the water foul: ducks, geese, etc from coming up onto the yard and dock, and leaving behind “gifts” for us. We swear by it now. We went with the silver metallic because it’s highly reflective in light, and helps deter birds better as it blows in the wind and creates a border. We’ve recommended our approach to a handful of others on our lake that have done the same with good success as well.