We're sorry the shirts aren't fitting the same, thanks for the feedback. If you ever experience issues with our products, we recommend contacting our customer experience team to get a quick and easy resolution.
“Nice shirt and good length. AT Tshirts seem to be too narrow around the shoulders creating a weird look. They fit differently than their longsleeve shirts.”
“The length of the “Tall” in its body (torso) is what I would consider extra extra tall. I don’t have that short of a torso but at 6’5”, many of these shirts are extremely long, so long, that I need to get a tailor to hem them so that they will fit properly. I have run into this problem a few times with American Tall (I do overwhelmingly love and appreciate this brand) in that just because I am tall and have wide shoulders and long arms does not mean that I want my shirt completely covering my butt and my side pockets. It’s usually the reason “tall” size in other brands still don’t work out. It’s almost like the sleeves weren’t made longer, but the body was. Like the shirt comes down to the top of my thighs, not my waist, and the vast majority of shirts should hit no more than a couple inches below waistline.”
“A great length and fit. I’m 6’2” and 240lbs and prefer something that hit around the family jewels. Style is simple and the burgundy compliments my skin tone well enough to get my wife’s attention. AT hit a home run with the slim style. Thanks”
“Great fit. Snug in the right places (arms & torso). Length is perfect for my size. More than enough cover for my 6’2” frame. Currently a slim 250lbs.”