“I thought I was going to love this top but ended up not really caring much for it. Another reviewer noted that the upper arm sleeve area was loose/baggy and I also found that to be true (my arms are on the thin side though). I found the material to be thinner and slinkier than what I was expecting and looking for. I also think the sleeves are not quite long enough. I got the XS Tall so the Extra Tall sleeves would likely be longer but the XS sizing doesn't come in Extra Tall so I'll probably just return. The Raspberry Space Dye color is really nice though. I'm 6'1" and 150 lbs. I often find the sizing of American Tall to be tricky as I'm regularly in between the Tall and Extra Tall sizing. I really wish this brand offered their XS sizing in the Extra Tall length, but understand there probably isn't much of a market for that size.”
We're sorry that you aren't completely happy with the fit and fabric. Thank you for your feedback, we'll pass it along to our design team. Feel free to contact our customer experience team if you have any questions!
“5'11", 140 lbs, Small Tall in raspberry fits well. The small tall in blue was bigger. I measured chest, waist, and bottom sweep of both, and the blue was 1-1.5 inches larger than the raspberry at each area. I returned the blue one bc too baggy. Both are looser than necessary in the upper arm area (between shoulder and elbow), as I've noticed on other American Tall long sleeve tops. I don't think tall women wearing size small tall need that much room there. You can see the excess material in that area on the models too. The material is lightweight, which I like. Colors are pretty. I wish the blue fit the same as the raspberry.”
We're sorry that the blue didn't fit the same, we appreciate your feedback and will pass it along to our team. Please feel free to contact us if you ever have questions!
