“My boyfriend bought these for me in a size Large a year ago. Then I lost 40 lbs and decided to buy them again in a size Medium. The material is completely different. The Large were soft and comfortable. They stretched appropriately. The Medium has no give. It's like putting on a pair of compression panty hose. I can barely get the bottoms over my heel and then I have to hop around to get in them. When I squat down, it squeezes really tight behind the knees. Now, I thought maybe they just needed to be washed to loosen them up. But no. They do not give. If you buy, go a size up. I bought a few different colors, and some colors give a little more than others but still, go a size up.”
Thank you for sharing your feedback! Our products are updated seasonally based on customer feedback which may result in slight differences in fabric, sizing, or cut compared to older styles. We're sorry these updates didn't meet your expectation! Feel free to reach out to our customer experience team if you have any questions!
“I ordered the large size in grey. I am 6 feet and weigh 128 pounds. The leggings were way too small. I have ordered these leggings before several times, always in black, and they fitted wonderfully. Something went wrong with production with this recent order. The sizing is off, or maybe it is the fabric not having enough stretch. First time I need to make a return to AT”
We’re sorry to hear this! Different styles and colors can have slight variations in measurements. Our customer experience team offers size recommendations, so feel free to reach out to them, they'd love to help!
“Paper thin! No stretch whatsoever! I’m a small but ordered medium and the ankles were so tight it was cutting off my circulation. I would NEVER work out in these!! Definitely returning #trash”
We're sorry you aren't completely happy with the fit and fabric of the Cotton Leggings, thanks for the feedback. Please feel free to contact our customer experience team if you ever have questions.
“I own several pair of leggings from AT. I purchased these to replace a pair I’ve worn out. They are very tight in the waist for a medium. I’m 5’9” 135lbs. A medium shouldn’t be this tight. You might want to size up. But then the legs may be too baggy. I want to love them as much as my previous. But something is off”
We're sorry to hear the Cotton Leggings aren't fitting as expected, thanks for the feedback. Please feel free to contact our customer experience team if you ever have questions.
“I ordered four different pairs of pants and leggings in size M, according to the website’s size chart. They all fit perfectly except for these leggings. They actually look great on me, and I can wear them, but it feels like I’d prefer a size L instead of M. The leggings don’t stretch at all and are very tight- even pulling them over my ankles takes some effort, despite the fact that I’m very slim. But once they’re on, they’re fine. I won’t exchange them for a bigger size, but if I had known beforehand, I probably would’ve ordered an L. The leggings are thin, fit like a second skin, and are not see-through.”
“I'm 5'9 with a 32" waist and bought a Large/Tall. They're long enough, and they're fine through the hips/legs, but the waist just floats on me - it's huge! Because there's no snugness at the waist at all, they slide down. If I could return the pair I wore today I would, but at least they were on sale. The others all going back. Bummer.
If you're generally more apple shaped these would probably be ok; or if you have narrow hips you could maybe size down.”
We're sorry that you aren't completely happy with the fit. Thank you for your feedback, we'll pass it along to our design team. Feel free to contact our customer experience team if you have any questions!
“Very comfortable and smooth. Not thick, just right, good for summer. I'm not tall but my legs are long... my inseam is 30" with wide hips and a narrow waist. These fit perfectly - the top of the pants doesn't stick out at the back over my bum and the ends pull down all the way over my angles with some slack or slouch at the bottom that sits on or over my ankle or quarter socks. None of my ankles are exposed. A far cry from the years of buying leggings that stop just over my ankle bone! Wish there were lighter colors - I would love light gray, beige, and white.”
“Tried these on and there's already a hole/run in them after 5 minutes. Hopefully I'm able to make an exchange because that's an expensive pair of leggings to have fall apart upon arrival.”
We're very sorry to hear that. It looks like our customer support team has assisted you with this. Feel free to reach out with any additional questions.
