“I’ve been wanting a shacket to throw on over casual attire and run errands on cool days or have extra warmth around the house. This fits the bill. It wasn’t as thick as I expected it to be, but the material is actually surprisingly warm. I am typically a M or sometimes L if I want something to be loose. I got the M Xtra T and it’s still a great oversized fit - I might have even been able to get away with a S - so don’t size up! I love the extra sleeve length of the XTall - not too much (I have ordered an XTall in another shirt where the sleeves were too long, but not the case with this). Only drawback is it’s kind of itchy, so I always wear a long sleeved under it. It’d be nice if it had a soft lining inside to give the option of wearing short sleeves, but not a big deal considering I’m wearing it bc I’m cold.”