“This is hands down the best mascara I have ever used, like it's insane! The packaging, oh my god, the packaging is insane and feels so high-end, of course, it's typically for Jeffree to really take it there with the packaging, but I feel like he's even out done himself on this mascara, it's terrifyingly gorgeous! I naturally have quite long, thick lashes, so when I tell you that this mascara made me look like I was wearing false eyelashes by the end believe me, the instant lengthening and volumizing abilities of this mascara has blown me away! The formula is more dry, which I prefer it means it doesn't get everywhere and is just easier to work with. I love the applicator it really does tend to each lash and it's not to far so it does perfectly for the lower lashes as well; oh, also I've always been thinking that I should really learn how to work with false lower eyelashes, I now have know no need to because this mascara does the job better than them; but if you can't leave with out a lash, like me in an Instagram pic, this mascara also makes the best base for false eyelashes. The formula is definitely an all-day water-resistant and smudge-resistant formula, which is perfect because I will now be wearing this whenever I go out; oh and it is the easiest mascara to remove ever I literally just put a Micellar water soaked cotton pad on for about 10 to 20 seconds and wipe gentle and it all just removes, almost in like little balls or something. In conclusion, I think Jeffree really nailed his first mascara and I can't wait to see what else his brand comes out with this year, hopefully, I'll make on to the pr list one day so I can play, discover, experience and review more. I can't recommend enough, if fact I beg you when this is restocked please grab it you won't regret it!”
“Love this mascara so so much. Comes off amazing as well unlike other mascaras mentioned in these reviews. I love it. Best mascara I’ve bought in a long time, I’ve been trying so many recently and now I’ve finally found one I’ll stick to. Makes my lashes look amazing”
“I can’t fault the packaging, it’s just the right kind of extra that you would expect from a Jeffree Star product. I was so excited to have this, but unfortunately it’s a huge disappointment. If you have short lashes avoid at all costs, it’s so ridiculously clumpy! There’s far better mascaras on the market that offer more bang for your buck. Save your money!”
“I struggle to find good cruelty-free, vegan mascaras, so had high hopes for this. Sadly it doesn't deliver. The wand is big, so I end up with transfer on to my eyelid, which is a pain in the bum. It does well with water resistance, but I've found I end up with crumbly flecks of black under my eyes by the end of the day. I also wish JS would think about landfill, the packaging is OTT. I realise a lot of people 'collect' this stuff and will use the tassle, but if this becomes your mascara of choice you're going to end up with a lot of plastic waste, and way more tassles than your burgeoning career in burlesque demands; so I feel he could at least offer a no-frills version that's cheaper? On the whole I'm disappointed, especially at that price.”
“I freakin love this mascara! I have long lashes which are quite sparse and don't hold a curl, however, this J* mascara boosted length, created and held a curl as well as making my lashes look more voluminous after just one coat.
I applied a second coat and my lashes were so long that they almost touched my eyebrows - if that isn't false lash effect then I don't know what is! The second coat was completely clump free and looked equally as good on my lower lashes as it did on the top lashes.
I love that the mascara is super lightweight, flake and smudge free with amazing longevity, zero eye irritation (I have sensitive eyes) as well as being super black.
The formula is on the drier side and I was unsure about the plastic wand head as I tend to prefer bristle brush wands but the mascara applied beautifully. The packaging speaks for itself and is definitely not a case of style over substance because the mascara is one of the best I have ever tried (I've been buying mascara, both drugstore and high end for over 30 years). I also really appreciate the additinal lash care ingredients so am hoping they will help boost my natural lashes over time.
If you are on the fence about trying this mascara then don't be! You'll totally be glad to have it in your life!”
