“I was so happy that I managed to purchase this mascara because I am a big J* fan. The delivery was very quick (it took only 2 days to arrive!) and the packaging was beautiful. I like the mascara but I think I expected more from Jeffree. This mascara is like a softer version of Bad Gal Bang by Benefit. It gives you length but not too much volume. It is very easy to remove and long lasting. However, I would not advise applying more than 2 coats because it gets a little clumpy and starts flaking. If you like very big, voluminous lashes this might not be for you. I will probably use it as an everyday mascara because I am in love with the packaging and it gives you considerably long lashes. 5/5 for Beauty Bay’s service and the packing but 3/5 for the formula... You decide :)”
“I received and tried this new Jeffree Star mascara, it's been a long time coming and I was extremely excited! It arrived perfect with no damage so that's good. I applied a first coat to the lashes and it was fine, nothing special just standard so I applied a second coat as most people do. The second coat is what ruined it, it was flakey, clumpy and that kind of mascara that gets in your eyes. I waited for it to dry and all it took to remove the mascara was to gently rub my lashes and it would just crumble off, no water or make up remover needed. I love J* cosmetics and I'm gutted about the formula, hopefully in time Jeffree will sort it out”
“I just received my delivery that included this mascara and I can 100% say it it is already the best one I’ve ever used. One coat goes a long way and made a massive difference in the look and length of my lashes!! This will now be my go to mascara forever!!”
“Black as night, lengthens, separates and lifts. And barring getting sprayed in the face with a pressure washer, this will not budge. If you want a new Holy Grail, then this is it.
I actually feel comfortable not wearing lashes with this.
The packaging is super cute, but if you want it to stand on your dresser, it won't.
As soon as this is back in stock, I will be stocking up on supplies as nothing else on market comes close to the longevity and the colour.”
“Ok, so I did my usual new mascara test; do both top & bottom lashes of one eye and just the top lashes on the other.
For the top lashes on both eyes-Amazing length and volume!!! No clumping. The second coat gave me that fab wispy “fake lash” look. The curve & look of the lashes stayed in place all day which is a huge plus point.
Unfortunately, the bottom lash line on the other eye didn’t fair so well. I used my standard one coat but it made my bottom lashes look really stubby. And then within half an hour it had flaked down my cheeks. Maybe it needs two coats on the bottom, but I like to stick to what works for me.
Removing was simple enough, I splashed my face with water, rubbed my eyes & a lot of the mascara balled off. For this, I can’t see it being water proof unless you’re not supposed to rub or touch your eyes at all.
Packaging is awesome....Glad I bought it to try & its certainly a collectors piece, however, I expected so much more from Jeffree. I’ll give it another few goes but will essentially stick to my drugstore brand.”
“Really happy with this mascara! I tried it on today and really loved how my lashes looked with this mascara! Not clumpy and spider leggy and feels so weightless like I can’t feel it on which is so nice! Love the packaging and the product itself! Defiantly will be buying another one when it restocks and will keep restocking myself on it I love it!”
