“I was sadly disappointed with the buckeye flavor. I agree that it seems like a normal peanut butter taste to me. I was hoping it had more of a chocolate taste to it or even pieces of chocolate in it. Lemon and Halloween egg are my all time favorites though!”
“Lemon cookie is my favorite thing! Frosted animal cookie is my second fav. Pumpkin pie has a strong nutmeg flavor but it is still good. The buckeye butter taste like regular peanut butter to me...if I focus on the flavor I get the chocolate, but I was not very impressed, sadly.”
“I had tried another flavor in the past and wasn't crazy about it, but I am MORE than pleased with the new chocolate PB buckeyes flavor! It's so creamy and yummy! Will be ordering more when it restocks!”
“WOW WOW! I am so incredibly obsessed. I have a major major sweet tooth and this has kicked my habits of needing sweets all the time. My favorite is to put it on bananas! Highly suggest these”
“I've had Halloween egg, blueberry and pancake and syrup....too bad there are always out of stock.
Thats it, get your customers hooked and then deprive them of the glory.”
“I just received my order yesterday, first time trying these nut butters. Cake pop is my favourite, then chocolate hazelnut, then frosted animal cookie almond butter. I found frosted animal cookie had a strong after taste that I didn’t like at first but I’ve been taking small spoonfuls right from the jar and it’s growing on me! I had the cinnamon crunch in my order but something happened and it didn’t come but I got a refund. Excited to try cookie butter!”
