Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.4 Rating 106 Reviews
“The cake was very beautiful as pictured in the catalogue. The icing was tasty but gritty.”
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
“Delicious.”
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
“Our relatives thoroughly enjoyed the Smith Island Cake...even ordered from your catalog for others in the family”
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
“Finally, a gourmet catalogue whose delivered items match the pictures!! This 9-layer cake was a hit at Christmas dinner. Thawed and cut beautifully with a hot knife. Wrapped half to re-freeze for New Year’s Eve. Many thanks for living up to expectations! You have won our loyalty.”
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
“The Smith Island cake was DIVINE! Thank you! Pat Sheridan”
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
“Very well received gifts ..”
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
“love it so ....get it for my son -in-law for his b.d. ev year”
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
“I LOOK FORWARD TO PURCHASING THAT CAKE AS MY GRANDMOTHER WOULD MAKE IT EVERY YEAR FOR MY BIRTHDAY (13 LAYERS) AND SO IT BEINGS BACK HAPPY MEMORIES WHICH LAST FOREVER. I'M SO GLAD YOU MAKE IT AVAILABLE AS I DON'T MAKE IT AS GOOD AS MY GRANDMOTHER DID AND YOUR'S IS JUST THE SAME AS HER'S.”
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago