“I teally am not sure how to review this, my dogs ADORE the tiddlers, i have one super picky eater, i decided to try this kibble when it went on sale- she refused to eat it. This may very well be her pickiness, nothing to do with the food. If your dog likes fish, it does have a fairly strong fish smell, its nice looking kibble, i had no idea how to rate this as she is a picky prima dona ! Keep the tiddlers coming!”