Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.5 Rating 169 Reviews
I used to make this cake from scratch every year. I no longer do that since yours is so delicious and authentic. FANTASTIC product!
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
The cake was a gift, but they told me it was terrific!
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
It was great
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Wonderful & moist
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Tiny thin delicious layers and chocolate icing like my southern aunts used to make!
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
This cake reminds me of my grandmother's chocolate cake recipe that she so lovingly made for us at Christmas time. Hands down a real favorite.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
I've had terrific desserts from Mackenzie, but I found the Smith Island cake a bit dry. Ice cream with it didn't help it much. Delicious flavor though.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
The cake was worth every penny and every calorie. I will definitely order again!
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago