Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business?? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.5 Rating 168 Reviews
Sent as gift to brother, his spouse and family. Will treasure picture of brother sitting in front of cake: with a big smile and about half of the cake(showing all the wonderful layers). Grandnephews big fans!Picture taken by niece who is an accomplished cake baker. Would recommend it as a gift.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
The cake was very good. The icing was a classic boiled cocoa and butter icing on moist thin cake layers. It does well through the thawing for the family dinner. Then it refreezes very well if not all eaten. It had rave reviews from all three generations of the family.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
excellent tasting cake
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
We whole family loves this cake!!!
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
My family said it is perfect!
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
Delightful cake! Reminds me of Boston Cream Pie , yet without the custard filling. A new go to dessert!
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
and everyone was wowed by the cake's sensational appearance. Makes a terrific family gift!
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago
Everyone loved this cake, and couldn't wait to have another piece! Beautiful as well as moist with an incredible icing. Getting another, soon, to celebrate one of our friend's upcoming birthday.
Helpful Report
Posted 5 years ago