Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business?? Click Here

Smith Island Cake Reviews

4.5 Rating 168 Reviews
Delicious! My family loved this cake,
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Love the cake but the frosting was and stayed "tackie" (wet, as if melted with no body). I really like the cake but don't remember the frosting being that thin. Will order again, next quarter.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
excellent quality and presentation
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Not as exciting as we had hoped. The picture was better to us than the actual cake. Good though.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
This also was a gift to my son. He liked it very much.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Reminds me of my Grandma chocolate layer cake, bring back memories of my childhood in Clearwater FL
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
I purchased 2 of these cakes as gifts. Both parties were thrilled and enjoyed eating them. The cakes go a long way. They are very rich in taste and looks. I am very happy with my purchase. Thank you.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
i ordered the smith island cake 4 yrs ago, it was soooo good, i was too late in 2020 but got one this year 2021, it was so not good , tasted like cake mix and sweetener, I was very disappointed. I truly don't understand
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago