Hi Shannon, maybe the best fit for you is our normal thongs called Starfish Orthotic Thongs. Our Fashion Strap range that you ordered is wider and the strap is a little bit loose to accommodate wider feet.
“I have difficult feet and these shoes are a great alternative to wearing closed in shoes all the time. Would recommend. They also stay on well when walking.”
“No wonder Aussie Soles are approved by the American Podiatric Medical Association. I have bought many pairs of Aussie Soles Starfish thongs over the years but I now have my first pair of Aussie Soles Fashion Strap thongs. These have the extra arch support, and how they do the job! Many thanks and I’ve actually bought a second pair of these❤️❤️”