Keith's Chicken Sauce | Keith's Reviews

4.4 Rating 685 Reviews

About Heatonist:

At HEATONIST, we work with the most passionate small batch hot sauce makers to develop new, never-before-seen flavors in the world of spice. As the official hot sauce partner of Hot Ones, we're trusted to curate new Hot Ones lineups and create their signature line of sauces.

Visit Product Page

“I am not a hot and spicy person so I was super excited to try Keith’s “not too” hot sauce to see if it would be something I would enjoy and also to help support Keith and the Try Guys. When I first got the sauce and tried it straight from the bottle I was shocked at how spicy it was! I was surprised it was something Keith could tolerate. But then I tried it on several things: pizza, eggs, and fried chicken. And oh boy did it make all the difference! It dialed back the heat to a perfect level and all the flavors of the sauce came through! And it really does pair perfectly with chicken. Again, I am not a hot sauce person but I would definitely buy this again. Plus the bottle art is just great! :) Great job to Heatonist and to Keith for this new creation!”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 years ago

“Friend of mine picked this up, and it's solid. For my personal tastes, i'd give it 3.5 (rating based solely on the sauce)as I find it to be a little better than your average sauce. Decent taste and mild heat. works with a few things, not just chicken. Confusing reviews because of fans saying 'congrats' -5*, 'I love Keith' -5*, 'bottle broke, didn't try it' - 3*(???), 'loved the sauce but $$$' -3*. This should be a rating of the product. Not Keith, not the shipping, not whatever the person who never tried it is rating... also a perfect 5* seems misleading since there are a couple 1* and several other ratings that are less than 5. In the end, it's worth a try to judge for yourself.”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 years ago

“Im super sensitive to spicy-ness and so when i watched keith’s sauce creation i KNEW it would be perfect for me because keith can’t do too spicy. AND I WAS RIGHT! THIS IS THE BEST HOT SAUCE, CHICKEN SAUCE, ANYTHING SAUCE. I cannot explain how amazing this is!! Im ordering again and again! Go TryGuys!”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 years ago

“I bought this with Los Calientes, and the comparison is amazing. Both excellent sauces, but completely, utterly different. Los Calientes hits the front of the tongue instantly with both heat and tang. This starts with "all the other flavors" up front and everywhere, but the not-insignificant heat and tang hit strongest at the back. It is a super strange contrast, which I can only guess involves some witchcraft (or possibly the capsaicin hides in the fat particles of the sour cream powder, and is released farther in.) Anyway, I can see why it works well for Keith--it won't hit his sore tongue wrong, and tastes effing fantastic.”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 years ago

“Oo wow wee wow. Love it. Great for marinating chicken. Great on ramen too, always keep 2 bottles in the house just in case. Goes with literally everything- eggs, pasta, chicken, fish, beef, sandwiches, you name it- it's perfected with this sauce. I've never heard of Keith from Try Guys but now I'm a big fan because this sauce rocks. I also tried putting some in my marinara sauce for meatballs, was good. Then put it in my lasagne, MIND BLOWN, best lasagne I've ever eaten 10/10. I love this sauce, the notes and flavours are perfect. Xoxo”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 years ago

“Wish I could've enjoyed the sauce but the bottom of the bottle was completely broken off.”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 years ago

“We blinked and half the bottle is already gone. Glad we got this, I need it on everything. I'd like to request a half gallon or gallon size. Perfectly spicy and vinegary and flavorful. Good on everything we've tried it on so far - pizza, sandwiches, fries! oh my.”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 years ago

“Received the bottle a couple days ago just in time for Christmas. Packaging was great and bottle intact. Is it worth $12 a bottle or $18 with shipping? I would say maybe. It’s a unique sauce that is very flavorful and different (delicious as well). The art on the bottle just makes u want to keep putting the sauce on everything bc it just looks so dang good, but would I love to see it cheaper so I can buy more without having to pay twice as much as regular hot sauce? Definitely. I would love to see the hot sauce more easily attainable financially and physically so more people are able to enjoy this deliciously unique hot sauce. * 3 stars as shipping took forever and I found it pricey for just one bottle of hot sauce”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 years ago