Everything Bagel Hot Sauce | Secret Handshake Food Co Reviews

4.6 Rating 402 Reviews

About Heatonist:

At HEATONIST, we work with the most passionate small batch hot sauce makers to develop new, never-before-seen flavors in the world of spice. As the official hot sauce partner of Hot Ones, we're trusted to curate new Hot Ones lineups and create their signature line of sauces.

Visit Product Page

“I received my two pack today. One bottle was broken, unfortunately but I emailed support and received a response a minute later with instructions to get a replacement. Luckily, only one bottle did not survive. I had leftover Popeyes in the fridge so I put some on my chicken tenders and it is so good. It's hot but not so hot that it ruins the flavor. If you like the flavor of everything bagels and some heat, I highly recommend.”

Helpful Report

Posted 2 years ago

“Extremely disappointed, being “Everything bagel” I was expecting a mix of several flavors to entice the tastebuds and instead got grey colored sauce that was bland as Pencil lead. I was surprised with all the good reviews, maybe I got a bad bottle in all fairness, but I doubt it and it went straight to the trash.”

Helpful Report

Posted 2 years ago

I’m so sorry this sauce wasn’t your cup of tea. We find it really sings on sharp cheese-flavored crackers and definitely warm English muffins with cream cheese. Or if you'd like a suggestion for something more to your taste, send an email to ilovehotsauce@heatonist.com

Posted 2 years ago

“All i can say is AMAZING!!!”

Helpful Report

Posted 2 years ago

“This is my favorite ❤️”

Helpful Report

Posted 2 years ago

“This is a very thick sauce and even when the bottle is shaken the sauce stays separate, resulting in an oily initial pour. Maybe I got a bad batch but it would be better in a squeeze bottle. Flavor is decent.”

Helpful Report

Posted 2 years ago

“Should have ordered 2 bottles ! Goes on everything!”

Helpful Report

Posted 2 years ago

“This is one of my favorite hot sauces I've tried. The flavor is great, I've been using it mostly on breakfast burritos but it is versatile. It is too thick to pour (which could just be the batch I received) so I have to use a toothpick to get it out. Also, the color is a very off-putting gray, so that was something I had to get past. Will definitely buy this again though!”

Helpful Report

Posted 2 years ago

“Saw Everything Bagel and just had to try this hot sauce. It's thick grey blend may look unappealing but the taste surely makes up for it. It's got good heat but not too intense and while I don't eat wings I sure enjoyed it on a turkey sandwich today.”

Helpful Report

Posted 2 years ago