“Sorry but I am not a fan. It was like eating a Slim Jim and not a juicy, plump wiener. I cooked according to directions and it fell flat in areas of taste, chewability, juiciness even with mustard and onions...I just tried the classic beef even though I had the entire selection. I will gift the rest of what I have to a family member who wants them. Maybe I am missing out on the true hot dog experience but I doubt it. I gave it 3 stars instead of 2 because of the packaging, selection and shipping.”
“Our neighbor's son over gave to his mom some Classic Beef Hot Dogs (8 packs) and she was kind enough to give us three packs. It was love at first bite! My wife having Celiac, they are great for her as they are gluten-free. They are now our standard hot dogs!”
“Great hot dogs, and fast delivery! Love the fact that the regular hot dogs aren’t made with a lot of garlic like some companies use. Brooklyn Hot Dogs are spiced perfectly so nothing overwhelms the meat taste. The long length is great! No more having more bun than hot dog!”
“I liked the casing alot but I thought the dog was a little too skinny. The taste was about average. Considering the shipping cost I think they are too expensive. I would buy them from a grocery store locally if I could.”
“As a first time buyer of their hot dogs, I am not impressed by the flavor. I bought the combination box with pepperoni, gyro, and buffalo chicken. The gyro had almost no gyro-type taste. The buffalo chicken is nicely hot, but unremarkable. I have not tasted the pepperoni yet.
Rather than the long, thin shape of these hot dogs, I would greatly prefer a shorter, thicker dog. Further, in my view, these dogs do not have enough fat for a truly good flavor. The pursuit of a healthier dog by the owners is admirable, but fat is flavor.”