The Brooklyn Hot Dog Co. Reviews

4.7 Rating 466 Reviews
91 %
of reviewers recommend The Brooklyn Hot Dog Co.

Write Your review

Tell us how The Brooklyn Hot Dog Co. made you happy
Help future customers by talking about customer service, price, delivery, returns & refunds.
Minimum 10 characters
Would you like to add a photos or videos?
Strengthen your review by uploading photos & videos.
Drag files here or browse
(Supported files: jpg, png, mpeg, ogg, mp4 & webm)
What's your name?
What's your email?
We need your email address to verify that your review is genuine
Please note that we may share your email with the company to verify your order.
Anonymous
Anonymous  // 01/01/2019
Not only did the product arrive not frozen but it was at room temperature to slightly warmer than room temperature. We were not sure if it was even safe to consume the hotdogs but we took a chance and boiled them. They tasted delicious but are giving a three star because of the packaging.
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
my wife, raised in northwestern Pennsylvania and I in Minnesota didn't really care for the taste of the hotdogs
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Beef, beef and pork where good. Didn't like the gyro but the other 2 where decent
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
I can’t say I was crazy about them…..wouldn’t buy again! Sorry!
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Did not really like them to much. I didn't like the skinny hotdogs like I thought I would.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
I thought the beef and pork were to skinny not filled enough. Taste was great between skinny and chewy casing I was a little disappointed
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
Skinny dog. Was good. Not fabulous
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
Enjoyed everything about the hot dog except the lack of meat and size. Too skinny.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
Didn't think they were any better than dogs I can buy at the grocery store, and for a lot less. Didn't care for the pepperoni at all.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
Good taste and mouth feel but way too thin for my liking.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
Sorry but I am not a fan. It was like eating a Slim Jim and not a juicy, plump wiener. I cooked according to directions and it fell flat in areas of taste, chewability, juiciness even with mustard and onions...I just tried the classic beef even though I had the entire selection. I will gift the rest of what I have to a family member who wants them. Maybe I am missing out on the true hot dog experience but I doubt it. I gave it 3 stars instead of 2 because of the packaging, selection and shipping.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
I am happy to have received your product in a timely manner
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
I liked the casing alot but I thought the dog was a little too skinny. The taste was about average. Considering the shipping cost I think they are too expensive. I would buy them from a grocery store locally if I could.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
As a first time buyer of their hot dogs, I am not impressed by the flavor. I bought the combination box with pepperoni, gyro, and buffalo chicken. The gyro had almost no gyro-type taste. The buffalo chicken is nicely hot, but unremarkable. I have not tasted the pepperoni yet. Rather than the long, thin shape of these hot dogs, I would greatly prefer a shorter, thicker dog. Further, in my view, these dogs do not have enough fat for a truly good flavor. The pursuit of a healthier dog by the owners is admirable, but fat is flavor.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
Good taste didn’t like the tough casing
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
The Brooklyn Hot Dog Co. is rated 4.7 based on 466 reviews