Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

The Brooklyn Hot Dog Co. Reviews

4.7 Rating 470 Reviews
91 %
of reviewers recommend The Brooklyn Hot Dog Co.

Write Your review

Anonymous
Anonymous  // 01/01/2019
Not my thing, disappointed they are so thin, not much different than a slim Jim on a bun. Definitely dont plump when you cook em. Taste was off as well.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Best hot dogs I’ve ever eaten. I bought the variety packs. Couldn’t decide which one I liked the best so I will have to order another variety package again. Consider me a lifetime customer. Thanks.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Absolutely loved them! We will order again!
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
These hot dogs take me back to growing up in New Jersey and visiting NY. We would hang out to the Push Cart owner whole consuming 2 or 3 dogs with onions in red sauce with mustard. Nice snap from the natural casing and they taste great. My first order was delayed, and when I wrote them, Tony sent me an apology via email and informed me he had sent me a new order. Great product and great service! I brought the all beef hot dogs.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
These dogs are so tasty, not too salty so the flavor shines through! We ordered the 5pack variety. The gyro dogs are soooo good. Our family is glad we found your company!
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Delicious hot dog.. would recommend to try them all! I will be ordering again!
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Not impressed!!
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Love your hot dogs.Great taste and very tender,Will order again. Thanks.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Have not tasted each variety yet .However,so far they are spectactular!!! It's like being back in Brooklyn.Will no doubt order again!
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Honestly 👎 no... it's really not a good hot dog... sorry boys, but that's my opinion..
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Absolutely love the taste, texture and snap of this hot dog. Do not taste salty like other hotdogs we have tried. Looking forward to tasting the variety of flavors of the rest of our order. Will definitely order more!
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Great flavor, snappy skin, great price
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
These are the real deal. Classic snap of the casing. A nice balance of flavor without being over the top salty. Obviously these are pricey but worth the treat. similar to the hard to find old classic natural casing Nathans or Sabrett but better and longer. I had to get footlong buns at Costco to fit these dogs that are long but skinny.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Skinny dog. Was good. Not fabulous
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
The hot dogs are super delicious. I will be a regular customer.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Excellent !
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Not very good. Hebrew national, Kirkland from Costco and Nathan’s all three blow them away.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Great dogs. I will never buy anything else.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
We got the variety pack and so far have only had the Pepperoni ones. Loved them.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
Best hot dogs I ever eat
Helpful Report
Posted 4 years ago
The Brooklyn Hot Dog Co. is rated 4.7 based on 470 reviews