“I will be breaking my review down into parts:
Before and after Toray left cryptonary for the cryptonary course and the VIP telegram
The cryptonary course
Let's start with the course, it's was a good introduction for people who have no experience in crypto currency, the technical analysis taught is free available in various places on line. If you had any experience trading and about crypto in general the course would not of been for you
Toray must of left cryptonary on bad terms as they deleted all of the videos that he had made voice overs for.
They have reupload some of these videos with a voice over from Shaun saying exactly the same thing Toray had said in the video's previously.
A few more unique videos were uploaded which have been a breakdown of how Shaun trades Which have honestly been amazing as it was good to see how a trader of that caliber analyses charts.
As they have been pushing this cryptonary V2 which is meant to be an updated version of the course they have not been uploaded any more education videos which would of been useful for traders who know nothing about technical analysis.
I received an email today that I they would be realising the new course in 'seasons' essentially you will need to be paying a monthly membership to gain access to various perks.
The problem with this is all the members who paid for The course before 2019 will only get a months free access. After this we won't get access to the educational course and will only be left with the free plan. This is a disgraceful business move as I payed for th educational course, which was removed and now I'll be left with a shell of the former course.
VIP telegram group (this group was free for members
Toray was on fire, constantly posting updates about technical analysis and fundamentals.
Content is still good but no where near as frequent as they only do swing trades and long-term investments. WhenToray controlled the group he did all the above plus short term trades.
As this was a free perk for the members them putting group away and basically putting a pay wall for the discord group is no concern for me as it was just a free perk.
I was pleased when Toray was the face of cryptonary. Now cryptonary seems a bit more money hungry, I just want the course I paid for and I will be contacting them about this. If I can't get the old course or an equivalent I will be looking for some other for of reimbursement.”
“The quality of the information is great ! I learnt so mich in a very short period of time. However I finished the course in two days and that cost me 500£, whoch in my opinion is pretty expensive. If we do the math, it comes to 100£ per chapter, and the quantity is very limited.
So I guess I like the quality but not the quantity...
Hopefully this will help you inprove in the future”
“With the First Trade from the Vip Telegram Group i do Money but with the Second Trade i lost a Little Bit of my bitcoins.
The Second Thing is i am from Germany an dont understand so much 😅
Nevertheless, I will make an effort and study the course to the end”
“If I was a total beginner to cryptocurrency and/or investing in general, then this course would garner 5 stars from me. Due to the fact that I am not a total investing beginner, the majority of the course can be seen as filler. Chapter 2 and some of 3, pretty much are all anyone needs to know who's investing OR daytrading. Great product overall, just should definitely be stated this course is for the beginner cause it's very overpriced otherwise.
“I would rate the course as good but requiring improvement.
Main reasons for this are:
a) there is currently a complete disconnect between the content on the Members Telegram and the course - the course specifies we are looking at long term investing only and emphasizes the dangers of trying to time the market, and the telegram is looking at day trading on a minute-by-minute timeframe, using a platform which is not covered in the course at all. Aware there is a day trading course on the way but at the moment I think it is dangerous to be looking at daytrading (especially with leverage) on the telegram as people like myself will try to get involved without the proper knowledge. Subscribers feel like they are missing out then lose money when they research it on their own and get involved as there's no course content covering the specifics.
b) There are things which are never explained on the course which are then referred to in the telegram - eg what is the right angular EMA line which always appears on the screenshots? We only know the 8, 18 and 200 from the course, so this one looks strange and makes us feel like we aren't being given the full picture.
c) Some areas of the course are wholly outdated, eg the lesson on how altcoins no longer follow BTC.
d) the content is mainly good, ie I found it very helpful learning to do the charting and use the different exchanges (except for the only one you seem to actually use, Bitmex). However I am currently down money and not sure why - no amount of re-watching videos which don't explain why is going to fix that.
e) I feel the insta feed is a little misleading - for example I took a trade which went 40% up on 25x leverage after a big move, which was great and people were sending in screenshots of their ROEs, however as the indication had been given that we would go higher I (and I imagine many other members) didn't take profits - was then annihilated when the market crashed the following day and ended up on 100% loss. None of this was posted on insta!
f) I think it is a bit irresponsible to be posting on insta about how everyone who doesn't take risk is a pussy; I understand that without risk there is no reward however it's easy to say you're risking 1BTC and making 3BTC on a trade when you have literally tens of thousands a week coming in in subscription fees from people buying the course. Obviously you took risks to get to that position, which is great, however encouraging people to risk their entire accounts on one trade, quit their jobs to take up trading full time etc doesn't feel like the right way to go.
All that said, I am hoping the daytrading course is cheap enough to be worth getting - feel like there is a lot I don't know still about how price action works and identifying big moves in the short term and I would be willing to invest a bit more given I've already sunk a fair bit into learning Crypto stuff! I don't feel like a confident investor off the back of the course, which is what I was hoping for based on the insta and the marketing.
Thanks for the base knowledge though, looking forward to learning more!”
“The course is well made but mostly focussing on people who are completely new to crypto. Going slightly more in-depth with the reasoning behind the choices would be nice. The VIP telegram, however, is a very nice extra feature and appreciated also the market breakdowns from time to time are very well made and appreciated. Even as a slightly more "experienced" crypto investor it feels good being part of the Cryptonary family.”
“I messaged you on IG but I’m so overwhelmed but bought the course. I need some help setting stuff up and understanding it all. I dm some questions.
I’m a single mom who is slightly ok at watch charts and doing math and rink I work Insurance. Can you maybe just get me a nudge how I can go between usdf to btc and what platform ect.
Also a bunch of people on ig keep rewearing me. Those are fictiois account right?”
“General improvements to the quality of the website would be good, as well as more content. Also the communication between customer and company needs to be improved. When I signed up I sent several emails and received no answers.
The videos that are there currently are good - however it would be nice to see more content.
The VIP Telegram is amazing, so cannot find fault there at all.
For the money, it is great value.”
“I didn't finish the course, but I thought it was okay. I am a very detailed person and I felt it barely scratched the surface. I thought I would get a more detailed understanding of crypto and blockchain. I think what makes up for it is the detailed telegram of your analysis. I also believe that your telegram is misunderstood alot because people there arent traders and based off of the instagram comments they only see is it going up or down. As opposed to looking at it in a trading range and confirmations.”