Pepper Sauce | Pirate's Lantern Reviews

4.6 Rating 106 Reviews

About Heatonist:

At HEATONIST, we work with the most passionate small batch hot sauce makers to develop new, never-before-seen flavors in the world of spice. As the official hot sauce partner of Hot Ones, we're trusted to curate new Hot Ones lineups and create their signature line of sauces.

Visit Product Page

“Flavor was good, it does has mustard flavor and it is very thick. The heat is low.”

Helpful Report

Posted 5 years ago

“A very tasty sauce. An easy 5 stars if it were even the slightest bit of hot. It's labeled as a 4/10 but in my opinion it is closer to a 2 at best. Mild heat aside it tastes strongly of mustard, fresh pepper and vinegar. The consistency is very good when chilled or room temperature and will stick to whatever you drench in it with ease, just make sure to give it a good shake or 5! I've tried it on hot dogs, a few cold cut sandwiches, off a spoon and some various types of chicken and it was exceptionally good. A great option if you're in the market for a vinegar and mustard based sauce that won't overwhelm you.”

Helpful Report

Posted 5 years ago

“I bought this for my parents and they love it. The one time I've tried it I was pretty blown away. Somewhere between a well-spiced hot sauce and hot mustard; it's just delicious all around.”

Helpful Report

Posted 5 years ago

“Second only to my favorite at the moment, this goes perfectly on cooked dark greens.”

Helpful Report

Posted 5 years ago

“This one's hit home with us. The wife loved it on BBQ cooked wings and poultry. Even went awesomely good on fries. Just the right heat and that unique taste! Two thumbs up to the fallen sailors' sauce!”

Helpful Report

Posted 5 years ago

“The heat on this is quite mild, any spicy food fan should be able to handle a spoonful no problem. The flavor on this is wicked good, I can't wait to try it on some ribs. I really wanted a good mustard base and this one delivers, the herbs are nicely balanced as well and it hits with flavor and heat similar to Caribbean Jerk seasoning. Very full flavored, very tasty, and a loveable spice level most people should be able to comfortably enjoy!”

Helpful Report

Posted 5 years ago

“It's a good tangy sauce and highly recommend to anyone who's not looking to get their taste buds signed off. On the heat scale, I rate it at a 1. Very good overall!”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 years ago

“I bought this not realizing what I was getting myself into. But sweet lord, this stuff is addictive. Vinegary, mustardy, spicey, and tangy. Throw it on avocados, hot dogs, sausage, burgers, sides, mains, hell it doesn't matter. It's my go to next to Los Calientes.”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 years ago