Pepper Sauce | Pirate's Lantern Reviews

4.6 Rating 106 Reviews

About Heatonist:

At HEATONIST, we work with the most passionate small batch hot sauce makers to develop new, never-before-seen flavors in the world of spice. As the official hot sauce partner of Hot Ones, we're trusted to curate new Hot Ones lineups and create their signature line of sauces.

Visit Product Page

“This sauce is so good I’ve had it for maybe 24 hours and I’ve already gone through half of it. I so wish I could get this in large quantities cause I just want to marinade and put this in everything. If you like mustard, get this. It’s not exactly spicy in how you may consider hot sauce but it’s amazing and you need to try it now.”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 years ago

“This sauce is the greatest thing too put on hot dog's, burgers, fries, & chicken, it has such a unique, and exquisite taste, I'll definitely be ordering more!”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 years ago

“If you love horseradish and mustard this is the sauce for you. Absolutely amazing on burgers/hotdogs or pastrami. Anything where horseradish or mustard is called for this sauce is going to work. Can't wait to use this in a marinade in place of mustard.”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 years ago

“I love mustard so I knew I would love this sauce. One of my favorite sauces for sure. It has a good amount of spice without being overbearing. Nice thick consistency after being refrigerated. I love this sauce on fried potatoes and also to just dip some chicken nuggets or tenders in. Haven't tried it yet but I imagine it would be perfect for a Cuban sandwich. Any mustard fan will love this sauce! Order two bottles at a time.”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 years ago

“If you like yellow mustard or "American Mustard" as we call it here in the UK, you will LOVE this!!! this has now become a permanent staple in my collection, perfect for anything you would normally use yellow mustard on like burgers & hot dogs but in my opinion it's even more versatile! for example i would quite happily eat a steak drenched in this sauce but i would never do that with mustard... so to sum up, this is my go to sauce for anything that's not chicken! (only reason being is i like a more bbq-ish type flavour profile when it comes to chicken)”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 years ago

“Not as mustard-y as I expected, but still super delicious! Very very flavorful and right in range for my spice tolerance. It's become one of my go-to sauces!”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 years ago

“Don’t smell it, just eat it. A little runny but who cares when it taste this good”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 years ago

“This sauce is awesome. Just got it today with my Last Dab bottle and am very happy I picked this as well. Really fantastic flavor with a nice little punch at the offset. The flavor really comes through though with the mustard and horseradish. I highly recommend this for anything you put mustard on or even something you wouldn’t.”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 years ago