“I was a loyal Knotty Knickers subscriber for several years, but unfortunately I’ve had to cancel due to ongoing issues.
The biggest problem is the number of duplicate items. At first it was occasional, but it’s now happening so frequently that I’m paying for items I already own. I tried to overlook it by donating extras, but it’s no longer financially reasonable.
I’ve also received items that don’t match my preferences — most recently boyshorts, which I don’t wear and shouldn’t have been included in my subscription.
Sizing has become a major issue as well. I wear an XL, but several recent items were clearly not true to size and fit closer to a medium. There seems to have been a change in manufacturing or sourcing, but no communication about it.
On top of that, the overall quality has noticeably declined over the past year.
I have reached out to customer service more than once, and the responses have been generic apologies with no real accountability or effort to resolve the issues — no solutions, no adjustments, and no form of compensation despite the ongoing problems.
At this point, it honestly feels like the company may be struggling with inventory and is sending whatever is available rather than curating orders properly.
This is disappointing because I really liked the concept and had been a long-time customer, but the service no longer delivers enough value to justify the cost.”
“Horrible customer service. I ordered two weeks ago. Haven’t received my order yet nor has the company responded to multiple emails or “contact us” requests. At this point, I just want my money back, but no one will respond…”
“I was very excited to get the 24 pack. When they arrived, many had strings and pulls in the lace and the sizing was inconsistent.
The colours must have been the leftovers. Some of them were really strange choices. I'm surprised that these are apparently their most popular styles.
The sizes although all were the labelled the same, they were not. Some are too big and others are too tight. There are only a few that actually fit properly. One pair went up to my breasts, and another were from Christmas. Clearly leftovers, not their most popular styles like they advertised. Spend the extra money and order something you actually like.”
“No response from customer service regarding returns/exchanges even though they assure you money back guarantee within 14 days. Shipping took forever and product very poor quality.”
“I used to have a subscription with them but cancelled due to getting duplicates, some of the thread was already coming loose once packaging was opened, one package was opened and the underwear was crumpled in it. I contacted customer service with no reply. Sent pics as well. Tried contacting them again and still no reply. Definitely not worth the headache.”
“The bralettes are soft and sized well. Very soft material. However, the order was severely delayed and only the bralettes were acceptable. Once the order finally arrived one of the items didn’t fit at all (despite being the same size as the other items in the order) and one arrived ripped. When contacted about the issue, the company issued a code for store credit on the damaged item. This means that I would have to pay almost the value of the item in shipping in order to get it one that is not ripped. I would recommend going elsewhere.”
“I bought 3 mystery packs and kept a total of 3 pairs. Most leave pantry lines or are oddly designed that will show under most clothing. Surprised that there is such a wide size discrepancy between each pair. Off the sizing chart. I should have been a large. In actuality. I probably would need an extra large to fit into most of these.”
“Leaving 5 stars as the website wont let me leave 1!!!! Item came over 10 days late and the material is abysmal. I am very disappointed. Furthermore, there doesn’t appear to be much cohesion with the sizes. Overall, awful experience would not recommend.”
“I bought 3 mystery packs and I thought I would end up with at least 4 or 5 that I didn't like. I didn't. I love every single pair! They are so cute and so comfortable.”
“I have been extremely disappointed. I knew $1.25 a pair did not mean high quality but I dis not expect them to fall apart om day 1 and day 3. I have worn three pairs. First pair stitching came undone. Second pair ok. Third pair the crotch panel is half way falling out because the seam opened and the material fell out. Also, the majority of the lace ones are way too scratchy to wear. I will never order these again. Won't let me add a picture.”
“Ordered a best sellers mystery 24 pack... took forever to receive them and you would think with buying 24 pairs they would be cute but they were mostly ugly. Quality was very mixed... Some were ok. And some were very cheap material and not sewn together all the way. Would not purchase again.”
“If I could give fewer stars, I would. Avoid spending your money with Knotty. Misleading advertisement, poorly made product and they will NOT accept returns despite their return policy published on their website. Also, whatever fabric they use is even worse than polyester, if that's even possible.”
“The quality is not good. I’ve already thrown most of them out or they are on their last legs after a few months of infrequent wear.
I do not recommend.”
“They are nice although....the sizes are not right. Ive been getting them for a couple years now and I have to give at least one pair out of three to my daughter every time I get my package. Also I think I will be unsubscribing because I began to get doubles and sometimes triple of the same pair of underwear. Sorry”
“My order hasn’t arrived after 3 weeks, when I contacted customer support to just send it back they told me they don’t accept returns…. Their website sure says they accept returns! Why did I pay $10 shipping on something I’ve been waiting 3 weeks on? Save your money and don’t make the mistake I did.”
“I am sadly disappointed in my first and only time shopping this site. The undies were fine, but sizing is a bit bigger than I'm used to. Unfortunately they did not send me my whole order. In fact, they didn't even send half of my order. I did not receive the 3 piece brief set, nor the Fire Sign crop top or shorts...those were significantly more expensive than the single dollar panties. The 10 piece mystery pack was only a 5 piece. I reached out to customer support and they said to take a picture of what I did receive. I sent the picture, which for my 83 dollar order, was only 11 pairs of underwear. For some reason they could not see the picture as an attachment in email, so I resent it several times, reformatted the picture, and since they said I don't have proof that I did not receive my missing items and that the shipping company had shown a picture of my package as delivered they would not be able to do anything. 83 dollars. For 11 pairs of baggy underwear. Buyer be warned! 🚩”
