Heatonist Reviews

Name: Heatonist
Address: 121 Wythe Avenue, Brooklyn, New York
Rating: 4.43

4.4 Rating 92 Reviews

87 %

of reviewers recommend Heatonist

About Heatonist:

At HEATONIST, we work with the most passionate small batch hot sauce makers to develop new, never-before-seen flavors in the world of spice. As the official hot sauce partner of Hot Ones, we're trusted to curate new Hot Ones lineups and create their signature line of sauces.

Visit Website

Write Your review

Tell us how Heatonist made you happy

Help future customers by talking about customer service, price, delivery, returns & refunds.

Minimum 10 characters

Would you like to add a photos or videos?

Strengthen your review by uploading photos & videos.

Drag files here or browse

(Supported files: jpg, png, mpeg, ogg, mp4 & webm)

What's your name?

Leave this blank if you'd like to publish your review anonymously.

(Optional)

Whats your email?

We need your email address to verify that your review is genuine

Please note that we may share your email with the company to verify your order.

Heatonist 5 star review on 4th March 2026

Jason

Heatonist 5 star review on 19th February 2026

RODNEY

Anonymous

Anonymous // 01/01/2019

Filter: Rated 4 None 5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Stars Helpful

“I think you’re pretty cool.”

Helpful Report

Posted 4 months ago

“So many options! I love trying all the new flavours. Finally made it to the Brooklyn store, all the way from Australia & the staff were great. Very helpful is selecting a few to bring home - plus I got to use a credit from all my online purchases!”

Helpful Report

Posted 4 months ago

“Heatonist is great, but they used to carry sauces they seem to not have any more and that makes me sad faced cuz it means they're no longer the one-stop-shop for all my hot sauce needs as they used to be - though they are still my first source. Love HEATONIST and I am a loyal customer. Just wish they'd expand and bring back sauces they used to sell”

Helpful Report

Posted 5 months ago

“Will order from again”

Helpful Report

Posted 5 months ago

“I have ordered from Heatonist for years now. Always happy with the product however I have had some issues with fulfillment. Also, I recently noticed on my last order that I'm no longer earning points toward free sauce. I loved that because about every other year I'd get an extra gift from it. Now, there's no discernable difference to order from you versus Amazon. That was a small perk but it allowed me to support "small business," even if I had to spend more for free shipping.”

Helpful Report

Posted 5 months ago

“I have loved the products showcased in your show since I first discovered you in 2021. They do not disappoint. I have tried many and we had a family game of "Hot Ones"! Grandma is still the "Eater of Heat" and her favorite is Cosmic Disco from that particular season. My proclivity for hot, hotter, and volcanic started after I was 18. My adventures in heat were quite tame at first. A chance meeting through a monthly pepper club allowed for a job working with Chili Today Hot Tamale for Rob and Dave -"The Heat Brothers" of New York fame back in the late1980's and early 90's...Needless to say our hottest peppers then were Scotch Bonnets and Habaneros. You have helped bring us to the brink and beyond with inspired sauces and carefully curated finds.”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 months ago

“I haven't tried the sauce yet, I'm waiting until October when I make Beef Jerky. I have a GUT feeling that The Last Dab will be great.”

Helpful Report

Posted 6 months ago

“Good selection. But always having things sold out is tiresome. Also have a lower threshold for free shipping.”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 months ago

“Love trying different hot sauces. Haven’t found my go to yet. I enjoy watching the show and seeing if there is any hot sauces that I might want to try.”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 months ago

“Love this company--super easy to work with and an amazing selection! Miss the rewards points but look forward to what is ahead.”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 months ago

“I love spice! Having a cabinet full of choices makes me happy. Some are just right on eggs. Some as the perfect addition to Asian food. Others give my BBQa kick. I tag and rate each sauce before adding a note for how to use it. The box includes a wide array of heat levels and accents. There is something for everyone and every meal.”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 months ago

Heatonist is rated 4.4 based on 92 reviews