Chuck Lawrence

“I have been using the stock PL tubes in my PrimaLuna Dialogue Premium HP integrated since I purchased it back in November 2017. I really have not had any complaints on the PL tubes but I really wanted to try some NOS tubes to see what all the fuss was about. I talked a few times with the great staff at Upscale Audio and ultimately decided to try out a couple Brimar's in the front two slots of the PrimaLuna integrated. I didn't do any critical listening for the first 50 hrs., but right out of the box I knew I was in for something special. The very first thing I noticed was that these tubes changed the tonal character of the amp in a good way. They sound more natural without having rolled off high's. Bass is punchy and the mid's are beautiful. After 50 hrs or so, the sound has gotten even better. Well worth the $$, no glare at all in the upper mid's. Cymbals have a very realistic sound. The originals were not bad, by any means, but the Brimar's take it to the next level........great upgrade!”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 years ago

“These tubes are seriously euphonic, and made my heart flutter when I put them into my headphone amp to listen to. Barely any noise on a highly sensitive (20 ohm) pair of headphones. Instantly bought more backups when these tubes wear out.”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 years ago

Robert G Gardner

Unverified Reviewer

“Mullard 12AU7 types can't even come close to competing with these. Remember, the price of NOS tubes is not a reflection of their quality, but of their rarity. Mullards do have glorious midrange, but their lows are muddy, indistinct and lack dynamics. The highs are very recessed, so much so that, if there are very subtle high frequency events, it is possible that you won't even hear them on the Mullards. These Brimars tubes have tight, tuneful, detailed and dynamic lows. The midrange is almost as glorious as the Mullards. The highs on these Brimars are clean, detailed, tuneful and extended. These are, in my opinion, the best 12AU7 in existence.”

2 Helpful Report

Posted 7 years ago

“I have owned the Primaluna Prologue, and now the Dialogue Premium Preamp. The Prologue needs to be opened up a bit from the stock Primaluna tubes. The Brimar tubes did the trick in the input stage, with a pair of Radiotechnique tubes in the output driver stage. WOW! GAME CHANGER! Everything opened up beautifully! Better than the stock tubes or the other tubes I had on hand from my last preamp's I have owned over the years! Then I bought the Dialogue Premium Preamp. More detail! The stock Primaluna tubes sounded great and were open already. So I put the Brimar into the driver seat of the Dialogue this time, and it is as perfect a sound as one could hope for! Simply outstanding! I just bought another pair to stash away for the future. I, like all audiophiles, pursue the perfect sound to our ears. This tube reaches that level easily. Thinking of stocking up more on this tube in the future.”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 years ago

“I installed the BRIMAR CV4003 / 12AU7 as a first level tube roll replacement for my stock Prima Luna tubes in my Prima Luna Dialog Premium HP mono blocks & Prima Luna Dialog Premium Pre Amp. These tubes out of the box sounded exceptional and at the 50 hour point have evolved into an exceptional addition for my system. The unexpected outcome was improved low frequency extension and control with open and transparent highs. I am sold. Ordered 10 more yesterday to do a full replacement of all 12AU7's in my system.”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 years ago

“Have been working to match the buffer and output tubes in my EE Minimax preamp to my new, very revealing Harbeth Super HL5 Plus speakers. Tungsram E80CC in the buffer just too much/too bright on top (and makes the preamp noisy), basic Mullard 12AU7 or M8162 are too soft, some nice RCA back plates and clear tops missing the liquidity I want. Just found the magic from Upscale - the Brimar 12AU7 in the buffer and the Mullard M8136 wrinkle glass in the output. All the transparency and air you want on top without being too bright/fatiguing, beautiful mids, crisp, full bass - the perfect balance. Just ordered more of each of these wonderful tubes in case I can't find them again!”

Helpful Report

Posted 7 years ago

“My Cary stuff is beautifully warm and uhh---liquid. Yeah, that's a good one, liquid. Out of boredom, I called Kevin and we decided that I should replace my Mullards with some Brimars just for grins. Wow, what a nice change on the top end. I think those in the know call it "air". All I know is, it's not bright or harsh but it's more alive on top. I've gone back and forth and the difference is always easy to hear. I love them. I might buy more just to have them in case Kevin goes nuts and raises the price.”

Helpful Report

Posted 8 years ago

“A brief continuation of my review below. The Mullard’s beat the Brimar’s in pure midrange beauty and texture, with more bass extension and slightly better tonality, and they have a bit more of a holographic soundstage. But the Brimar’s win in terms of a great top to bottom balance, detail, coherence, and they possess such a pleasant ease about them that is very natural and captivating. I can’t pick a winner as I like them both very much.”

Helpful Report

Posted 8 years ago

Brimar CV4003 / 12AU7 Platinum Grade / No Cryo Reviews