Feltman's of Coney Island Reviews

4.6 Rating 671 Reviews
89 %
of reviewers recommend Feltman's of Coney Island
The order was redirected and shipped back to you. You acknowledged this. I contacted you three times last week and I tried to follow your replacement steps bur got nowhere. Please respond and resend my order.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
OK since you asked, The last order I placed I had to ask where it was because it looked JUST LIKE THIS?!! This is a second order I placed almost 2 weeks ago, marked as PAID and UNFULFILLED. Then you ask for a review?!! Get it together Feltman's!! I still do not have the order!!?? Order Felt18280 February 19, 2022 08:57PM Product SKU Price Quantity Total Route Package Protection - $2.55 ROUTEINS18 $2.55 1 $2.55 Feltman's Natural Casing Hot Dogs - 3 x 1lb pack GM3PK-1 $44.99 1 $44.99 Fun Sized Hot Dogs (Casing) - 6 Pack GM6PK-3 $79.99 1 $79.99 Subtotal $87.54 FAM50 Discount $-39.99 Shipping (Flat Rate) $9.99 Tax (Maryland State Tax 6.0%) $2.40 Total $99.93 USD Billing Address Payment Status: Paid Order Felt18280 February 19, 2022 08:57PM Product SKU Price Quantity Total Route Package Protection - $2.55 ROUTEINS18 $2.55 1 $2.55 Feltman's Natural Casing Hot Dogs - 3 x 1lb pack GM3PK-1 $44.99 1 $44.99 Fun Sized Hot Dogs (Casing) - 6 Pack GM6PK-3 $79.99 1 $79.99 Subtotal $87.54 FAM50 Discount $-39.99 Shipping (Flat Rate) $9.99 Tax (Maryland State Tax 6.0%) $2.40 Total $99.93 USD Billing Address Payment Status: Paid Chester MD 21619 United States Shipping Address Fulfillment Status: Unfulfilled
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
ordered on Jan 26 were is my order at have not got it
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Extremely Disappointed. Would not buy again. When broiled, orange grease filled the tray below. AWFUL. What a waste of money.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
I emailed you about how to cook your hotdogs but never heard from you. I tried the ones with the skin on but didn't like. I cooked in microwave and that might have been the problem .
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
I won’t be ordering again. You ruined my fathers 85th birthday with mistake after mistake. Huge fail. Heartbroken daughter.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
wHERE IS MY ORDER??????
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
We were not happy with the quality of these hot dogs at all. Outragious price for being hot dogs that we could not eat!. The skin was sooo tough & hard to chew. Not even our small dog wouldn't eat just one!. I still have frozen ones that I will try to give away to someone to eat. The mustard was good but again much too expensive for a small jar. I commend you as veterans but you need to go back to the drawing board on your merchandise. No more for me. We are retired people & can't afford to throw money away such as this!!. Nancy Criswell
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
sorry to post this as they are a veteran-owned company and we are vets as well - but this was not tog our liking- hot dogs tough skin tough meat and funny red-colored the hamburgers they shrunk so much we had to double up so as to have a decent meal.....
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
We did not like the hotdogs or the mustard. It was disappointing! Sorry for the bad review, but you asked and I had to be honest!
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Sorry guys, Your hot dogs were quite a disappointment. Tried 2 of them prepared in the oven per your instructions and have no desire to have them again.Must be a regional thing (Zweigle's hots) Sorry, Lee
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Your company was very fast in shipping my order. My order was a day later then it started when I was notified the shipment was to be delivered.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
There were chunks of inedible something throughout the hotdogs. They were gross, total disappointment and a waste of my money. I served them at a family BBQ and I am totally embarrassed. People were throwing them in the trash. A refund would be nice.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
I thought I ordered foot long dogs but they were regular size very disappointed!!
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
They did not taste good
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
The worst hot dogs I ever tasted.will not buy again
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
They were greasey. Yuk I will stay with NATHANS.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
As I previously communicated, my order received two days after shipping arrived at room temperature. I placed it in the freezer immediately, but I'm afraid to eat it. Dry ice next time?
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Hot dogs took 6 days to get here. Were warm and thus not safe to eat. Package included mustard but no mustard in our shipment. I emailed Feltmans and no response.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
I honestly have never tried your dogs. I ordered 6 packages of your natural skinned dogs. They were shipped from Ohio. They were supposed to arrive in two days Fedex said they were running late and would deliver them in three. They unfortunately lied to me. They said they attempted to deliver on day three and that I wasn't home. Boy my wife and I were and we have cameras they never tried. Fedex promised to send the driver back that same day they didn't. Fedex was instructed not to deliver them on day four if they wouldn't return on day three. Fedex delivered the warm dogs on day four and promised then refused to come back to get them. I dropped the dogs off at Fedex drop of center Fedx again redelivered the dogs to my house three days later. I saw the driver down the street and chased him through two towns with the package of now obviously rotten dogs. I blocked the driver in a driveway gave him back the package and told him never to return to my property. So no I haven't tried your dogs and will never order a shipment of them again.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Feltman's of Coney Island is rated 4.6 based on 671 reviews