“I'am disappointed with my experience at Pinch A Penny store 209 in Sarasota, Florida. When I had questions about my pool and needed help troubleshooting a problem, the owner was not willing to assist or provide useful guidance. I also sent emails asking for help, but never received positive response back. Good customer service includes being available to answer customers questions, especially after a purchases. Unfortunately, that was not my experience, and I cannot recommend this store based on the lack of support and communication.”
“Zero stars!!!! Horrible work!!! Stay away!!! After speaking with many local pool companies we decided to hire Robert to install our new pool liner May 2024. He appeared knowledgeable and trustworthy. After installation we noticed wrinkles in the pool, which Robert said he would come back and fix. Robert came by in October and attempted to get the wrinkles out, however the wrinkles were only made worse. Fast forward to Summer 2025 and we have sink holes in our pool! We immediately contacted Robert, who came to take a look and said he would be back the next week to fix it. He never showed up. We attempted to contact him through calls, leaving voicemails, sending text and speaking to the co-owner who said she would immediately contact him. It has been over 4 weeks with no response. I would not recommend Robert to anyone. Pool liners are not inexpensive. He took advantage of us and now we are out the funds we paid him and stuck with an awful liner job. They apologized on Facebook, however saying sorry doesn’t fix a thing. Update: So to respond to your post, are you going to fix it or just say sorry and leave us out of over $5,500? Update 2: This company has not fixed any of their work and when they say they are sorry and will address with their employees there is nobody to address and she and Robert are the owners. Update: I have contacted the BBB and received an extremely deceitful response from the owners. After filing a complaint with the BBB I received a response from the owners stating they told us we needed a pump for groundwater and we declined, due to the cost. First, we were never told that, if so we would have paid the $1500 for the pump. What sense would it make to get a new liner that would only work for a year. Secondly, what ethical company would complete a job they knew they couldn’t complete properly. I did not expect any more out of this company as you can tell by their automated response they do not value their work or their costumers. I responded very clearly as to why and proof of their lies. Do not use this company unless you want to be taken advantage of.”
“Started service just over a month ago. Worst service ever. Every time I ask a question I get 2 or 3 different answers
Tech was going to put chemicals directly in my skimmer. That can ruin your pool.”
“Used their pool service in November and December, our pool went from cloudy to dark green. They told us to drive to the store to pick up and add chlorine to our pool. When I cancelled service the woman hung up on me. What is company did was criminal.”
“Their service tech is in and out in 3 minutes. Spoke to the manager who was rude and unprofessional above having them come back and finish the service I paid for. He canceled my agreement.”
“We have been using Pinch A Penny at 2251 Citrus Blvd. Leesburg, Florida. We recently bought a house that had a hot tub. The brand is HotSprings with the salt water system. We went to Pinch Penny to get their advice on how to treat this correctly. They told us to use bromine. As it turned out, their advice was wrong. Their response was that it was our responsibility to know how to treat the water in the hot tub.
They did not have the knowledge to prescribe the chemicals we needed to operate the hot tub correctly. They sold us a startup kit and extra chemicals. We were unable to get the water balanced. This caused us to go to a Hot Springs Outlet. Pinch A Penny was having us, place bromine and chlorine into the water at the same time. These chemicals are indirect conflict with one another. We brought this information to the staff, including the manager. They would not give us a refund on the unused chemicals. They said they are not supposed to give any refunds on sold product. They did not honor their policy for refunds on new and unused product. They are more interested in selling product then giving accurate advice for the use of the chemicals they sell.
They have lost us as a client indefinitely!”
“Purchased a part that the employee got out of his truck. When I got home part was not needed and I tried to return it in the bag that the employee gave me with the receipt. Refused to take it back an refund money. Stated they could not take it back because they would not sell product in the bag that I had. So lessoned learned don't trust this store.”
“We had our pool resurfaced by Pinch A Penny Panama City, FL. We thought they did a good job. The warranty states protection against delamination for 10 years, as long as monthy water samples were brought in, which we did... always buying the products needed, and doing as recommended.
A few years later we noticed a small area of delamination and let Jimmy Legg know about it. It took SEVEN MONTHS to get any response, then he quoted us $1,300 to repair a 3x4 inch area under warranty. The entire resurfacing was only about $5,000. I can't understand paying $1,300 for a small area under warranty.
Over the years, we have probably spent approximately $15,000 with this company. We were good customers. We will never do business with them again, nor will we recommended them. So disappointing. I can see now why they have such low ratings. I just wish I would have never done business with them.”
“Don't buy a polaris freedom from them, two months and counting for warranty parts replacement. Excuses have been plentiful. What a sham for $1300 pool cleaner still under warranty.”
“I requested weekly pool service. The price was ok. Everything was acceptable. But he mentioned that they don’t empty the skimmer basket unless you pick the deluxe service at a higher price. I asked a question about them not emptying the skimmer basket and he informed me he wasn’t interested in my business and he declined me service. He said my attitude was bad, just over a simple question. I have used them for 8 years of testing and buying chemicals. Needless to say I’m deleting them from my contacts. Business is way too good. Lost me. Punta Gorda on south 41. I wish I got his name. He is in service.”
“Deranged employee became abusive for no reason when I utilized their curbside service which they offered to those of us who needed it. The elderly man was offensive in every way and tried to burst large chlorine jugs into my trunk of my suv, when that didn't work, he continued his offensive behavior; when I told him I had a medical condition, he continued to mock me and ran into the store so I couldn't confront him. The manager told me she would not do anything about this incident; as a loyal customer for 15 years, I will not return to this menagerie.”