Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

PrimeFish Seafood Co. Reviews

4.8 Rating 442 Reviews
93 %
of reviewers recommend PrimeFish Seafood Co.
Read PrimeFish Seafood Co. Reviews
PrimeFish Seafood Co. 5 star review on 15th September 2025
Victoria
PrimeFish Seafood Co. 5 star review on 13th September 2025
Gary
PrimeFish Seafood Co. 5 star review on 1st September 2025
Sarah
PrimeFish Seafood Co. 5 star review on 2nd August 2025
Erin
PrimeFish Seafood Co. 5 star review on 2nd August 2025
Erin
PrimeFish Seafood Co. 5 star review on 2nd August 2025
Erin
PrimeFish Seafood Co. 5 star review on 2nd August 2025
Erin
87
Anonymous
Anonymous  // 01/01/2019
Was not a big fan. Purchased 5 lbs of snow crab meat at $75/lb which arrived in two days, still frozen in a premium shipping box. We had a meal with the first 1 lb package (prepared per Primefish's guidance) and found it just OK at best. Crab tasted a little fishy and not at all what I would have expected from a premium product. Their butter was good, but average. Not sure if I'll even prepare the remaining $300 worth! Sadly, we get better tasting crab at the mexican restaurant around the corner! We were so excited to try PrimeFish, but unfortunately I would not recommend their product based on my experience. Hopefully this was just an anomoly. For us, we wish we had the money back to spend on better tasting products elsewhere.
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Crab legs are very small and came all defrosted Not worth the $350 I payed!
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Very fishy
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Wasn’t happy this time. In the past I’d give 100 stars. My order seemed like it was soaked in water. So disappointed.
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Extremely disappointed in the quality! The videos that you watch, the man is able to just bite the snow crab claws just as tender, as if they were fresh. The order I received they were almost edible and had to throw them out. The snow crab leg meat Is almost as inedible as the crab claws. Needless to say for the several hundreds of dollars that I spent I am 100% extremely disappointed and will not be ordering again. I did not want this to be my story. I wanted to love this product. I was very very excited….
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Unfortunately, The lobster did not taste very fresh. It almost tasted like it was rancid. This is a very expensive service and we expected to have fresh lobster. Very disappointed!!
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Not happy food was half defrosted when I got it To slow in delivery Bad buy
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Hi Craig, Thank you for your review, we apologize your experience was not positive. We offer a 100% guarantee should there be any issues with your order when it arrives. We ask that you file a claim should you experience any issues so that we can best assist you with a resolution. Your order shipped on Monday, 1/29 and delivered to you on Wednesday, 1/31. This is the 2-day shipping we promise. Thank you, Olivia
Posted 1 year ago
I was very disappointed in my order after following the directions to defrost it it was waterlogged in the bag I then had to drain it in a colander towel, dry it with paper towels over and over and over again, and when I did cook it the following day it had a very fishy flavor to it, so I just want you to know I was very disappointed and will not purchase that again. Cathy Neve
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
Hi Cathy, Thank you for your review. We apologize your experience was not the positive experience we hoped it would be. We offer a 100% guarantee if you are not satisfied with your order. Please reach out to me at contact@getprimefish.com. Thank you, Olivia
Posted 1 year ago
Very disappointed after thawing the crab cocktail in the fridge overnight because it was water soaked therefore the texture was slimy and tasteless
Helpful Report
Posted 1 year ago
PrimeFish Seafood Co. is rated 4.8 based on 442 reviews