Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

americantall.com Reviews

4.6 Rating 3,005 Reviews
88 %
of reviewers recommend americantall.com
Read americantall.com Reviews
americantall.com 5 star review on 23rd March 2026
Courtney
americantall.com 5 star review on 23rd March 2026
Courtney
americantall.com 5 star review on 6th March 2026
Chané
americantall.com 5 star review on 6th March 2026
Chané
americantall.com 5 star review on 18th February 2026
Anonymous
americantall.com 5 star review on 21st December 2025
Tammy C
americantall.com 5 star review on 10th September 2025
Margie
181
Anonymous
Anonymous  // 01/01/2019
My large pants were too long and too big. I’m 6 feet and 160 pounds.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 months ago
We're sorry to hear that the pants were not a perfect fit! You're welcome to exchange it for a different size through the return portal on our website. Our customer experience team offers size recommendations, so feel free to reach out to them, they'd love to help!
Posted 3 months ago
I really wanted these jeans to work because American Tall gets the length right, which is hard to find. The length was perfect and the fit in the thighs and behind was great, but the waist was too big and there was extra space in the crotch that made them feel too long in that area. I could have had them tailored, but the amount of correction needed just wasn’t worth it. I appreciate that the brand focuses on tall sizing — it just wasn’t the right cut for me this time.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 months ago
We're sorry to hear this! We understand it can be difficult to find the perfect fit so we offer size/product recommendations from our Fit Experts! Please feel free to reach out to our customer experience team, they'd love to help!
Posted 3 months ago
I had to return this order. It has now been over 7 days since the return was delivered to American Tall and I have not had any notification that the return has been processed. Typically, they have been responsive but now with their new 'hands-off' approach to customer service, I find it lacking.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 months ago
We're very sorry for your experience! Our customer experience team has reached out through email, and we hope their assistance has helped! Feel free to contact us if you have any questions.
Posted 3 months ago
Fabric is extremely thin. I am 6 feet tall but ordered extra tall, so I had to cut off about 3 inches counting new hem. I have very long legs and high waist. I do like the raised stretchy waistline, as it softly hugs the torso. I won't order any more pants this thin. Might do for opera night. I weigh 174 and take a large. Extra large was way too roomy though I have big hips.
Helpful Report
Posted 3 months ago
We're sorry you aren't completely happy with the pants purchased, thanks for the feedback. Please feel free to contact our customer experience team if you ever have questions.
Posted 3 months ago
I find the sizing is all over the place. It really needs to be more consistent.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We're sorry to hear you've had difficulty with our sizing, thanks for the feedback. You're welcome to get in contact with our fit experts if you're having trouble finding the right size. They're happy to provide a recommendation!
Posted 4 months ago
I love that American Tall offers more options for taller people. I am not so much tall but rather just have a longer insteam. I was very disappointed that even though they are an online only store, they charge for returns. I am very picking about my pants/trousers, and was trying something new in the hopes I would like it. However, they were not my style and did not fit how I wanted them to. While American Tall might be a good option for some people, unless they change they return policy, I will not be shopping from them in the future.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We're very sorry that you're disappointed in our Return policy, thanks for the feedback. If you'd ever like to learn more about returns/exchanges we recommend checking out our Help Center: https://americantall.zendesk.com/hc/en-us. Additionally, if you ever have questions about sizing please feel free to contact our customer experience team.
Posted 4 months ago
Quality of clothes is fine. Predictably in sizing is not. One never know if inseam length will be what you order. I ordered two pairs of pants in two colours, two different times and in each shipment one was shorter by a whole inch! That inconsistency is unacceptable. Wish there was a body one could talk to. Before putting it in the mail I want to know what the actual inseam is so I don't go through the hassle of returning it.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We're very sorry that you've had difficulty with our items. If there is any specific issue you are facing, we recommend contacting our customer experience team so they can assist you. You may do this through our website: https://americantall-gen.ada.support/chat/
Posted 4 months ago
I really like the concept of American tall. As a 6’2” woman, the struggle is real! I’ve bought about 10-15 items from AT over the past year, and it’s been more misses than hits. The material is often very poor quality, and clothes seem to not last long. Also, the structure of a lot of the items need work.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We're very sorry that you've had difficulty with our items. If there is any specific issue you are facing, we recommend contacting our customer experience team so they can assist you. You may do this through our website: https://americantall-gen.ada.support/chat/
Posted 4 months ago
My husband loves the navy ones we received but I am still waiting for the grey, we still have not received. Thank you
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We can see you've worked with our team and now have the product. Please let us know if you have any further questions.
Posted 4 months ago
Slub tee material is thin. I was expecting regular cotton. I was embarrassed that I gave it as a gift. The $27 tee that looks like it was $5.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We're sorry you aren't completely happy with the fabric of the Slub Tee, thanks for the feedback. Please feel free to contact our customer experience team if you ever have questions.
Posted 4 months ago
I feel like the extended sizes are almost always sold out, like the extra tall jeans on the bigger end are never available when I look.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We're very sorry to hear the sizes you'd like are sold out, thanks for the feedback. You can sign up via email to be notified when the sizes come back in stock on the product pages! Please reach out to our customer experience team if you have any questions.
Posted 4 months ago
I bought these items for my teenaged son who is six feet tall. The length of the clothing was perfect. However, the turtleneck sweater was a slight disappointment. The seam at the neck ripped. I had to sew it. That led me to rate my order a three.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We're very sorry to hear the Turtleneck ripped along the seam, thanks for the feedback. If you ever experience issues with our products, please get in contact with our customer experience team. We'd like to ensure you receive a quick and easy resolution.
Posted 4 months ago
Early days but I'm a bit hesitant. The fit is nice. There were several stray white threads at the outside seams. They did not simply pull free. I had to cut them. That rather makes me question the workmanship. The other thing is the zipper. Its operation feels rough, and it seems quite SHORT. I would cheerfully pay more for a little better quality and faster shipping (WEEKS). But now that Levi's sold Dockers and Dockers only come in a 34" inseam, I will probably repurchase these if they hold up over time.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We greatly appreciate your feedback, thanks for sharing. Please don't hesitate getting in contact with our customer experience team if you ever have questions.
Posted 4 months ago
I love having these cotton bottoms. BUT, I'm forever needing to pull them up, whether wearing large or extra large. The waist area needs to be more secure, not narrower, but more secure. Can you do this?
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We're sorry the waistband has been giving you issues, thanks for sharing. If you ever want to provide feedback or suggestions, you can use this link! This way, we can be sure your information is passed along to the right team: https://americantall.ada.support/chat/?greeting=6153497937b9c167b27734ff
Posted 4 months ago
Purchase the same leggings last year and the size was a perfect fit. Purchase them this year again and they are extremely small! I purchased a medium and they fit like a size small and maybe even a size extra small. I can barely fit them over my ankle.... I was unable to return them because I had already taken the tags off assuming they would fit like last year.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We greatly appreciate your feedback, it will be forwarded to our concerned team! Our products are updated seasonally based on customer feedback and evolving trends which may result in slight differences in fabric, sizing, or cut compared to older styles. However, we remain dedicated to maintaining the quality of our products. We’re sorry if these updates didn’t meet your expectations and appreciate your input as we continue to improve! Please reach out to our customer experience team if you ever have questions, they'd be happy to help!
Posted 4 months ago
This might be the first review I have ever written, but wanted to make sure people are aware of my experience so far. I am a 6'2" skinny male. I wear 30x36 jeans which have become hard to find. I was excited to get my orders and thrilled that they fit. However after wearing just one time, the first pair had stitches coming apart. The second pair I wore for the first time, also had stitches coming apart, but in a different area. To be fair, I have sent this information to the company in hopes of them doing the right thing. Regardless, I would be very concerned about purchasing these jeans. I have been a long time Levi's guy and seriously still have jeans that I have worn for 30+ years, and never a stitching issue. I really hope this works out well as the jeans feel good, and fit well. But for now, I would question the quality. Hopefully a fluck of some sort.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We're very sorry to hear this. It looks like someone from our customer experience team is assisting you with this. Please let them know if you have questions!
Posted 4 months ago
Nice quality, but fits big for label size.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We're sorry the item was a bit too big, thanks for the feedback. Please feel free to contact our customer experience team if you ever have questions.
Posted 4 months ago
I don't love these, but they are definately long enough. What I don't love is the fit. I used the AI fit and went with the middle size suggestion, they are about a size too big in the waist/body area, but do fit well in the leg/length. I know I could have returned them and gotten a different size but I didn't have time to wait - shipping seems to take longer than I expected. Another thing that I think American Tall should look into is the sewn in tags on the waistband, these are itchy and would be much better silkscreened. Lastly, I feel like the front pockets need to be ironed after being laundered (washed and dried), they are wrinkly and bunchy. This could be due to the size being too big but I am not sure. Overall, I would recommend these jeans, but be cautious of the size you order. I know I will try a different size if I order in the future.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We greatly appreciate your feedback, thanks for sharing. We're sorry the fit wasn't perfect, and we'll ensure to forward the comments to our concerned teams! Please feel free to contact our customer experience team if you ever have questions, they're happy to help!
Posted 4 months ago
Fit was great, but it arrived with a hole in the seem😔
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We're very sorry to hear this. It looks like someone from our customer experience team is assisting you with this. Please let them know if you have questions!
Posted 4 months ago
They were a little smaller than size.
Helpful Report
Posted 4 months ago
We're sorry the item was smaller than expected, thanks for the feedback. Please feel free to contact our customer experience team if you ever have questions.
Posted 4 months ago
americantall.com is rated 4.6 based on 3,005 reviews