Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

CustomMade Jewelers Reviews

5.0 Rating 5,036 Reviews
99 %
of reviewers recommend CustomMade Jewelers
5.0
Based on 5,036 reviews
Shipping & Delivery
Delivery Methods
Postal Service, Courier
Average Delivery Time
Next Day
On-time Delivery
99%
Accurate And Undamaged Orders
100%
Customer Service
Communication Channels
Email, Live Chat
Queries Resolved In
2 - 3 Hours
Customer Service
5 out of 5
Read CustomMade Jewelers Reviews

About CustomMade Jewelers:

We don’t just sell engagement rings—we help you make one that’s only yours. Designed from scratch. Crafted by hand. Made to mean more.

Visit Website

Location:

90 Sherman St, CustomMade.com,
90 Sherman St, CustomMade.com
02140

CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 18th November 2026
Katherine Kolden
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 24th August 2026
Jaden Dosanjh
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 23rd August 2026
Anonymous
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 22nd August 2026
Caden Palmer
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 22nd August 2026
Anonymous
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 20th August 2026
Emily Livingston
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 20th August 2026
Paige T
1761
Anonymous
Anonymous  // 01/01/2019
“I would've liked the the mountains and plants to be a little more defined, but other than that, I love how the ring turned. There's nothing more special and unique than making your vision come to life. The idea of having something nobody else would have brings your own love to the project.”
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 13th November 2026
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
“My experience was very good I had to push the date back a few times and my project manager never made me feel like I was being rushed everything was on my own time and any minor corrections I wanted they did with no problem and even offered their own insight to customizations”
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
“I worked with Eloisa to create my fiancée’s s perfect ring. They did such a great job at putting together all of my ideas and were super helpful in getting that first sketch to perfection. Having all of the sketches and 3D renderings was super helpful to get the vision right and they also made a precious gift to my partner to see how the ring came to be!”
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 12th November 2026
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
“CustomMade helped bring my fiancee's ring to life. They take all the difficulty out of the ringmaking process and allow you to focus fully on the stuff you care about - stone choice, ring details, all the good stuff. The staff were amazing at answering questions, giving recommendations, supplying a variety of options, and overall being very flexible and transparent about the ringmaking process. Most importantly, my fiancee loved the final product! She keeps looking at how it sparkles in the light and she loves the intricate details. CustomMade is a great choice for selecting custom ring designs. They offer so much support, both during the ring creation process and after. I'm excited to come back in the future for a wedding band! Special thanks to my project manager Mollie.”
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
“The whole process was very easy. Being part of the the creation process as well as all the options when designing was very fun and informative. Highly recommend!”
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
“Custom made has such a simple process for bringing your ring to life. My fiancé absolutely loves her ring. Pricing was reasonable, communication was great, and I could not be happier.”
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 10th November 2026
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
“I have ordered 7 pieces from Custom-made (5 pendants and two rings). I have been very pleased with the whole process, start to finish. They were timely, professional, reasonable, and listened.”
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
“I cannot say enough great things about Custom Made. From start to finish, the entire experience was nothing short of exceptional. Their professionalism, attention to detail, and commitment to perfection truly set them apart. They kept me informed every step of the way, making sure I was involved throughout the entire design and creation process. The communication was outstanding, and the quality of their craftsmanship exceeded my expectations. I was so impressed with the first piece they created that I loved it so much I had to come back and have a second piece made. That alone speaks volumes about the quality of their work and the experience they provide. If you’re looking for custom jewelry, a company that takes pride in perfection, and a team that genuinely cares about bringing your vision to life, I highly recommend Custom Made. Five stars all the way.”
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
“The customer service was fantastic, answered every question I had and helped me make some decisions I was on the ropes about! Ring was made, came in looking and feeling fantastic! Great company to work with!”
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
“My partner and I had a wonderful experience working with Ryn throughout the whole process. She was beyond helpful and answered all of our questions. I would recommend CustomMade to anyone looking to custom make an engagement ring! They truly are amazing and provide so many options :)”
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 9th November 2026
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
“My overall experience with this company was amazing. I approached them with my idea and through some back and forth messages with my project manager, Allison, they were able to bring my idea to life. I was thrilled with the finished product. It’s exactly what I had hoped it would be.”
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
“The experience I had with CustomMade was extraordinary! They were super helpful and transparent throughout the entire process. They responded quickly every time I had a question. I was even able to send back the finished engagement ring when I did not love how the accent stones looked the first time. I would recommend CustomMade to anyone looking to design the perfect ring for their partner. My fiancée loves it and can't stop admiring it in the light.”
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 8th November 2026
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
“Great quality work. They worked with me designing the ring over a few months. The ring looks great.”
Helpful Report
Posted 1 week ago
“My experience was very good! I came in not really knowing what to expect. I took inspiration from my girlfriend’s Pinterest and they ran with it. We ended up having to change the whole design because my girlfriend’s friends said she would want a different look to it, And they were totally willing to redo the whole thing. It ended up looking really beautiful! And I am so excited to propose with the ring. I also was surprised by the box that it came in with all the items that we would need when proposing. It was soo cute! I am overall very happy with my experience!”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 weeks ago
“We had the best experience. I had been to local jewelers who told me that what I wanted was not possible, and that it would be much more expensive, and they never quite got my vision right. CustomMade was incredible!!! My project manager was fantastic, she did an incredible job explaining to me my options and communicating between me and the design team. She helped me decide between styles I liked and was just so kind and very responsive. My ring is gorgeous, and in perfect condition, and made exactly the way we discussed. It is everything I could have wanted and more. We will definitely be returning customers for anything custom we want done in the future. 10/10”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 weeks ago
“My experience with CustomMade was very smooth and easy! The project manager worked diligently to ensure I receive the exact product that I wanted, and the communication process was very quick as well!”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 weeks ago
“Ring turned out exactly how I wanted. Very responsive staff who were quick to help me turn my ideas into drawings/ mock ups”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 weeks ago
“I ordered a custom made engagement ring, they helped me design it and worked with me through all the different iteration of the ring I had until we came up with the perfect 1 of a kind ring for my 1 of a kind fiance. There was a minor set back with stones being back ordered and we look at other option, by the time we decided the stones had arrived. The were very good at everything they did. I gave them a hard deadline even with the back order it arrived days before. The only thing I found difficult is they dont work the weekends so you dont get a response til the beginning of the week. I work weekends but I understand not everyone does and I like that there is a work life balance there. Overall my experience was amazing and I will definitely work with them again. One other note is the pictures and videos you so do not do it any justice. It is way more amazing in person. I won't spoil it but the packaging when it arrives is so amazing”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 weeks ago
“Great experience! Emily helped me every step of the way and the ring came out exactly as I imagined.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 weeks ago
“Emily made this process incredibly simple and special. She took the time to make sure I was in love with what we were creating and she communicated in detail at every step and in between. CustomMade Jewelers is wonderful, trustworthy and I would happily use them again.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 weeks ago
CustomMade Jewelers is rated 5.0 based on 5,036 reviews